The Best IR Device? A Comparison | DBAL, ATPIAL, VAMPIRE, PERST, MAWL

Published on December 16, 2021
Duration: 33:24

This guide details a rigorous testing protocol for comparing infrared (IR) laser and illuminator devices, as demonstrated by 9-Hole Reviews. It emphasizes the importance of controlled environments, consistent equipment specs (NVGs, cameras), and objective performance metrics to evaluate devices like the DBAL, ATPIAL, Vampire, Perst, and MAWL. The analysis focuses on illuminator performance as the key differentiator for target identification at various ranges, distinguishing between civilian-legal aiming lasers and powerful illuminators needed to overcome photonic barriers.

Quick Summary

Illuminator performance is the primary differentiator for IR devices, crucial for target identification beyond simple aiming. While civilian-legal IR lasers suffice for aiming within 100 yards, superior illumination from devices like the Steiner DBAL-D2 or B.E. Meyers MAWL-C1+ is needed to overcome photonic barriers and identify targets at greater distances. Rigorous testing protocols are essential for accurate comparisons.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Context
  2. 02:30How Night Vision Works
  3. 04:39Photonic Barriers
  4. 06:06Test Course and Equipment Specs
  5. 08:09Device Testing: 25m Range
  6. 18:40Device Testing: 75m Range
  7. 22:28Conclusions and Takeaways

Frequently Asked Questions

What are photonic barriers in the context of night vision?

Photonic barriers are intense light sources that can overwhelm night vision devices (NVGs). They cause NVGs to auto-gate or focus on the bright light, making it difficult or impossible to see targets in the surrounding shadows. Powerful IR illuminators are needed to overcome these barriers.

Which IR devices are best for target identification at longer ranges?

For effective target identification at longer ranges (beyond 100 yards), devices with superior illuminator performance are crucial. The Steiner DBAL-D2 and B.E. Meyers MAWL-C1+ are highlighted as providing better illumination compared to many civilian-legal laser illuminators tested.

What are the key factors to consider when comparing IR devices?

Key factors include illuminator performance (output and beam pattern), laser power for aiming, effectiveness against photonic barriers, and overall device reliability. Consistent testing methodology with documented NVG and camera specs is essential for accurate comparisons.

Are civilian-legal IR lasers sufficient for all night vision applications?

Civilian-legal IR lasers are generally adequate for aiming within approximately 100 yards. However, for effective target identification at greater distances or in challenging conditions, more powerful IR illuminators are necessary to provide sufficient light amplification through NVGs.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from 9-Hole Reviews

View all →