PUMPKINS vs .30SC 5.7x28 .357Sig & 10MM

Published on November 4, 2024
Duration: 9:51

This video compares the terminal ballistics of four handgun calibers (.30 Super Carry, 5.7x28mm, .357 Sig, and 10mm Auto) fired into water-filled pumpkins. The 10mm Auto demonstrated the most significant effect, followed by 5.7x28mm and .357 Sig, with .30 Super Carry showing the least. The presenter notes that water-filled pumpkins are used to simulate soft tissue and create a more dramatic effect than dry pumpkins.

Quick Summary

In a ballistics test using water-filled pumpkins, the 10mm Auto with a 200-grain hollow point delivered the most significant terminal effect, outperforming .357 Sig, 5.7x28mm, and .30 Super Carry. Water-filled pumpkins are used to simulate soft tissue for better observation of projectile performance.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Setup
  2. 00:58.30 Super Carry Test
  3. 02:315.7x28mm Test
  4. 04:12.357 Sig Test
  5. 05:0710mm Auto Test
  6. 06:30Ammunition Used Breakdown
  7. 07:33Energy Comparison
  8. 08:25Results and Surprises
  9. 09:03Conclusion and Winner

Frequently Asked Questions

How does 10mm Auto compare to .357 Sig in terminal ballistics?

In this test using water-filled pumpkins, the 10mm Auto with a 200-grain hollow point demonstrated a more significant effect than the .357 Sig with a 125-grain hollow point, despite similar estimated energy outputs. The 10mm was the clear winner in terms of visible damage.

What is the purpose of using water-filled pumpkins for ballistics testing?

Water-filled pumpkins are used to simulate soft tissue, providing a more realistic representation of how a projectile will perform in a living target. This method allows for better observation of bullet expansion and energy transfer compared to dry pumpkins.

Which caliber performed the least effectively in the pumpkin test?

The .30 Super Carry caliber, used as a baseline and compared to 9mm performance, showed the least effect on the water-filled pumpkins. Its impact was described as similar to what might be expected from a standard 9mm round in this test setup.

What ammunition was used for the 5.7x28mm caliber test?

For the 5.7x28mm caliber test, the video utilized 40-grain jacketed hollow point ammunition. The results showed a slightly larger split on the pumpkin compared to the .30 Super Carry, indicating more immediate energy transfer.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Buckeye Ballistics

View all →