Q&A 44: My Workout Routine, NATO-Caliber Brownings, & Defend the Alamo!

Published on August 11, 2020
Duration: 61:34

This Q&A session from Forgotten Weapons covers a range of firearms topics. Ian McCollum discusses the potential of balanced recoil systems, the obsolescence of the 8mm Kurz cartridge in favor of 7.62x39mm, and historical attempts to chamber M1 Carbine-style actions in .223. He also touches on the challenges of modern gunsmithing, the M14's quality control issues, the safety of Carcano actions, and the viability of AR-10s as scout rifles. The discussion extends to the effectiveness of large bore rifles against WWI armor, the practicality of silver bullets, and the operational differences between the MG 34 and MG 42.

Quick Summary

The 8mm Kurz cartridge is largely obsolete due to its large case head, which necessitates excessively long magazines. The 7.62x39mm cartridge offers similar ballistics with a smaller case head, allowing for more compact and efficient magazine designs, making it the practical successor.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Morning Drink
  2. 01:00Balanced Recoil Systems
  3. 02:058mm Kurz Cartridge Future
  4. 03:44M1 Carbine in .223?
  5. 06:06Floatplane Platform Review
  6. 08:29The State of Gunsmithing
  7. 12:17Chessboard of Hamas Reprint
  8. 14:08M14 Relevance Today
  9. 14:59M14 vs. M1 Garand Praise
  10. 16:43Carcano TS Safety Check
  11. 20:06AR-10 as a Scout Rifle
  12. 21:48Making Bullets Out of Silver
  13. 23:33WWI Anti-Armor Rifles
  14. 25:40John Wick Movie Armament
  15. 27:32Exercise Routine for Shooting
  16. 30:04.22 LR Rebated Bullet
  17. 32:11Firearm Factory Tours
  18. 33:35Bullpups vs. Traditional Rifles
  19. 35:29Transparent Pistol Panels
  20. 38:303-Round Burst vs. Full Auto
  21. 39:52Arming the Alamo Defenders
  22. 42:55Ohio Gun Collectors Show
  23. 43:43Night Sights on Handguns vs. Rifles
  24. 45:19WWII German Machine Gun Loadouts
  25. 49:40Best Way to Sell Guns
  26. 55:08Discarding Patreon Questions
  27. 56:501919 A4 to 7.62 NATO Conversion
  28. 60:00CMMG Radial Delay Blowback
  29. 61:03Conclusion & Patreon Call

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the future of balanced recoil systems in firearms?

Balanced recoil systems may offer significant benefits, potentially leading to more complex yet ruggedized designs. While not expected to be a revolutionary change, they could become a more common feature in future infantry rifles.

Why is the 8mm Kurz cartridge no longer relevant?

The 8mm Kurz cartridge is based on the 8mm Mauser with a large case head, leading to excessively long magazines. The 7.62x39mm cartridge, with its smaller case head and similar ballistics, is a more practical successor, allowing for more compact magazines.

Can an M1 Carbine be converted to fire 5.56x45mm NATO?

No, the M1 Carbine receiver is too short for the 5.56x45mm cartridge. However, experimental .22 caliber high-velocity cartridges based on the .30 Carbine were developed, and the Winchester Light Rifle was essentially a scaled-up M1 Carbine in .224 Winchester.

What are the main issues with the M14 rifle?

The M14 suffered from significant quality control and manufacturing problems, making it difficult to achieve consistent accuracy across different contractors. Its intended role as a replacement for multiple firearm types was also considered overly ambitious.

Are Carcano rifles safe to shoot?

Yes, Carcano actions are generally safe. Claims of them being prone to blowing up are considered 'fudd lore.' Safety issues typically arise from modifications like re-chambering or deactivated firearms with drilled barrels.

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →