Wax Slug vs Cut Shell vs Rifled Slug

Published on June 5, 2026
Duration: 14:29

This video from Banana Ballistics explores the effectiveness of DIY shotgun slugs, specifically wax slugs and cut shells, compared to standard rifled slugs. The instructor, demonstrating significant expertise in ballistics and shotgun performance, conducts accuracy, penetration, and steel target tests. While the DIY options show promise in certain areas like reduced penetration, they exhibit inconsistency and generally fall short of traditional slugs for self-defense or hunting applications.

Quick Summary

Expert ballistic testing compares DIY wax slugs and cut shells against traditional rifled slugs for accuracy, penetration, and steel target impact. While DIY options show reduced penetration, they suffer from inconsistency, making them generally unsuitable for self-defense or hunting compared to standard rifled slugs.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Birdshot as Slug
  2. 00:19Rifled Slug Accuracy Test
  3. 00:30Low Recoil Rifled Slug Details
  4. 00:51Rifled Slug Wad Issues
  5. 01:11Wax Slug Construction
  6. 01:38Wax Slug Accuracy Test
  7. 02:04Cut Shell Construction
  8. 02:14Cut Shell Test 1 (4 Slits)
  9. 02:54Cut Shell Test 2 (2 Slits)
  10. 03:10Cut Shell Test 3 (1 Slit)
  11. 03:5325 Yard Accuracy Test
  12. 04:02Wax Slug 25 Yard Test
  13. 04:31Cut Shell 25 Yard Test
  14. 04:46Steel Target Test Setup
  15. 05:02Rifled Slug Steel Target Test
  16. 05:24Wax Slug Steel Target Test
  17. 05:49Cut Shell Steel Target Test
  18. 05:59Drywall & Ballistic Gel Test Setup
  19. 06:18Rifled Slug Drywall Test
  20. 06:41Wax Slug Drywall Test
  21. 07:45Cut Shell Drywall Test
  22. 08:43Conclusion: DIY Slug Recommendation

Frequently Asked Questions

Can birdshot be modified to act like a slug for shotgun use?

Yes, birdshot can be modified to act like a slug by binding the pellets together with materials like wax or by cutting slits in the shell casing. However, the effectiveness and consistency of these DIY slugs are significantly lower than traditional rifled slugs, making them generally unsuitable for self-defense or hunting applications.

How do DIY wax slugs and cut shells perform in terms of accuracy compared to rifled slugs?

In accuracy tests, DIY wax slugs and cut shells showed some promise but were generally less accurate and consistent than standard rifled slugs. While they can group, the spread is often wider, and issues like pellet or shell separation can occur, impacting overall precision at various distances.

What is the penetration difference between rifled slugs, wax slugs, and cut shells?

Standard rifled slugs exhibit high penetration, posing an over-penetration risk in home defense scenarios. Wax slugs and cut shells demonstrate significantly less penetration, with wax slugs showing limited shot grouping and cut shells creating a large wound channel but with less overall depth, making them potentially safer regarding bystander risk.

Are DIY shotgun slugs like wax slugs or cut shells recommended for self-defense?

No, DIY shotgun slugs like wax slugs and cut shells are not recommended for self-defense. Despite their potential for reduced penetration, their inconsistency in accuracy, reliability, and performance makes them unreliable compared to commercially manufactured ammunition designed for critical situations.

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Banana Ballistics

View all →