9mm vs 45 ACP, WE END THE DEBATE. The Human Torso Test.

Published on February 13, 2022
Duration: 24:44

Garand Thumb, adopting a 'Dr. Garand Thumb' persona, conducts a detailed ballistic test using human torso analogs to compare 9mm Luger and .45 ACP calibers. The test evaluates various ammunition types, including FMJ, hollow points, and high-pressure loads, demonstrating that modern 9mm ammunition can rival .45 ACP performance. The instructor concludes that 9mm's higher capacity and lower recoil make it a practical choice, emphasizing training over caliber.

Quick Summary

Garand Thumb's ballistic test using human torso analogs concludes that modern 9mm Luger ammunition performs comparably to .45 ACP. He favors 9mm for its higher capacity and lower recoil, enabling more accurate follow-up shots, and emphasizes that shooter training is more critical than caliber choice for self-defense effectiveness.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to 9mm vs .45 ACP Debate
  2. 02:18Ammunition Selection and Specs
  3. 05:00The Human Torso Analog
  4. 05:35Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) Testing
  5. 07:46Hollow Point Performance (Speer and Remington)
  6. 11:09Norma MHP and Buffalo Bore Testing
  7. 13:39Final Assessment and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main conclusion of Garand Thumb's 9mm vs .45 ACP ballistic test?

Garand Thumb concludes that with modern ammunition, the ballistic difference between 9mm Luger and .45 ACP is marginal. He favors 9mm due to its higher capacity and lower recoil, enabling more accurate follow-up shots, and stresses that training is more important than caliber choice.

How does Garand Thumb test the performance of 9mm and .45 ACP ammunition?

The test utilizes sophisticated human torso analogs containing simulated bone, organs, blood, and muscle tissue. This allows for a realistic assessment of how different ammunition types interact with skeletal structures and internal simulants, providing detailed terminal ballistics data.

Does FMJ ammunition perform well in self-defense scenarios according to the test?

The test showed that Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) rounds, regardless of caliber, resulted in minimal tumbling or fragmentation within the torso analog. This indicates that FMJ is suboptimal for self-defense compared to modern expanding hollow point ammunition.

Which caliber does Garand Thumb recommend after the ballistic testing?

While acknowledging the marginal ballistic difference with modern ammunition, Garand Thumb leans towards 9mm Luger. He cites its advantages in higher magazine capacity and reduced recoil, which contribute to better control and faster follow-up shots in a defensive situation.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Garand Thumb

View all →