Biden Tells Supreme Court To Uphold NY Carry Permit Restrictions!!! NYSRPA v. Bruen

Published on October 4, 2021
Duration: 9:26

This analysis breaks down the Biden administration's legal arguments in the NYSRPA v. Bruen Supreme Court case, where they urged the court to uphold New York's restrictive concealed carry permit laws. The speaker, an expert in firearms law, critiques the administration's reliance on historical interpretations and argues against the use of intermediate scrutiny, advocating instead for a text, history, and tradition standard for Second Amendment cases. The video highlights the core issue: whether New York's 'proper cause' requirement for concealed carry violates the Second Amendment.

Quick Summary

The NYSRPA v. Bruen case challenges New York's requirement for a 'proper cause' to obtain a concealed carry permit. The Biden administration urged the Supreme Court to uphold these restrictions, arguing for the permissibility of regulating handgun carriage. The speaker critiques this stance, advocating for a 'text, history, and tradition' standard over intermediate scrutiny.

Chapters

  1. 00:01Biden Admin Appeals to Supreme Court
  2. 00:08Channel Support and Sponsorships
  3. 00:28Firearms Policy Coalition Support
  4. 00:39Case Overview: NYSRPA v. Bruen
  5. 00:53Oral Arguments and Biden Administration Brief
  6. 01:06Background of the Bruen Case
  7. 01:29Central Question for the Supreme Court
  8. 01:41Biden Administration's Arguments
  9. 01:55Argument 1: Historical Regulation of Firearms
  10. 03:16Historical Context and Licensing Restrictions
  11. 03:32Distinguishing Prohibition from Restriction
  12. 03:40Argument 2: Regulating Handgun Carriage
  13. 04:42Application of Heller and Scalia's Dissent
  14. 05:05Permissible Restrictions vs. Broad Prohibitions
  15. 05:30Critique of Administration's Argument
  16. 06:21Intermediate Scrutiny vs. Text/History Standard
  17. 06:46Lower Courts' Use of Intermediate Scrutiny
  18. 07:36Argument 3: Prohibiting Handgun Carriage in Urban Areas
  19. 08:05New York's 'Need' Requirement
  20. 08:24Call for Supreme Court Action
  21. 08:35Conclusion and Viewer Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the NYSRPA v. Bruen case about?

The NYSRPA v. Bruen case concerns New York's concealed carry permit restrictions, specifically the requirement for applicants to demonstrate a 'proper cause' or 'special need' to carry a handgun in public for self-defense.

What position did the Biden administration take in the Bruen case?

The Biden administration urged the Supreme Court to uphold New York's restrictions on concealed carry permits, filing an amicus brief arguing that such regulations are permissible under the Second Amendment.

What legal standard does the speaker advocate for in Second Amendment cases?

The speaker advocates for the 'text, history, and tradition' standard for interpreting the Second Amendment, criticizing lower courts for frequently using intermediate scrutiny, which they believe favors government interests over individual rights.

What is the core Second Amendment question before the Supreme Court in Bruen?

The central question is whether New York's denial of concealed carry applications based on a lack of 'proper cause' or 'special need' violates an individual's Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Armed Scholar

View all →