BREAKING: 27 States Tell SCOTUS to Crush Hawaii’s Carry Ban

Published on November 28, 2025
Duration: 11:36

This video provides an expert analysis of the legal challenge against Hawaii's firearm carry ban, led by Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen. It details how 27 states are urging the Supreme Court to strike down Hawaii's Act 52, which is described as a 'default carry ban' and a violation of the Bruen decision. The content highlights Hawaii's reliance on questionable historical laws and its openly hostile stance towards Second Amendment rights, warning of potential nationwide implications if Hawaii prevails.

Quick Summary

Twenty-seven states are challenging Hawaii's Act 52, a law creating a 'default carry ban' where firearms are prohibited on private property open to the public unless explicitly permitted. Led by Montana AG Austin Knudsen, the coalition argues Hawaii disregards the Bruen decision and treats the Second Amendment as a second-class right, potentially impacting carry rights nationwide if upheld.

Chapters

  1. 00:0027 States Challenge Hawaii's Gun Ban
  2. 00:11Montana AG Leads Coalition Against Hawaii
  3. 00:31Hawaii Disregards Bruen Decision
  4. 00:53Attorneys General Done Playing Games
  5. 01:17Hawaii's Unconstitutional Firearm Carry Restrictions
  6. 01:43Austin Knudsen's Strong 2A Stance
  7. 02:24Baerskin Hoodie Sponsorship
  8. 04:06Hawaii's Act 52 and 'Vampire Rule'
  9. 04:26DOJ Supports Challenging Hawaii
  10. 05:15Act 52 Creates De-Facto Gun-Free Zones
  11. 06:1427-State Brief Shreds Hawaii's Logic
  12. 07:08Hawaii's Reliance on Fake History
  13. 08:08Hawaii's Hostile Motives
  14. 09:50States Fear Widespread 'No Guns Unless Permission'
  15. 10:28Reaffirming 2A and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Hawaii's Act 52 and why is it being challenged?

Hawaii's Act 52 is a law that establishes a 'default carry ban,' meaning firearms are prohibited on private property open to the public unless the owner explicitly grants permission or posts a 'guns allowed' sign. It is being challenged by 27 states as unconstitutional and a violation of the Bruen decision.

How are 27 states challenging Hawaii's gun ban?

Twenty-seven states, led by Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen, have filed a brief with the Supreme Court arguing that Hawaii's Act 52 disregards the Bruen decision and treats the Second Amendment as a second-class right. They seek to have the Supreme Court strike down the law.

What historical laws does Hawaii cite to justify its gun ban?

Hawaii's legal arguments for its gun ban rely on what critics call 'fake historical tradition,' citing only two laws: a 1771 New Jersey anti-poaching law and an 1865 Louisiana 'Black Codes' law aimed at disarming freed Black Americans. The Supreme Court has warned against using such outliers.

What are the potential implications if Hawaii wins its case?

If Hawaii prevails, other states could adopt similar 'no guns unless permission' policies, effectively bypassing explicit carry bans and significantly weakening Second Amendment rights nationwide. This case is seen as a crucial test for the enforceability of the Bruen decision.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

View all →