Cache.Deals

California Federal Judge OFFICIALLY ANNOUNCED NEW 2A LAW

Best Iron
Published on June 18, 2024
Category: 2nd Amendment & Law
Duration: 12:01

A California federal judge issued a permanent injunction against the state, preventing the denial of Second Amendment rights to individuals with non-violent felony convictions from other states that have been vacated or nullified. This ruling specifically impacts plaintiffs Paul McKinley, Stewart, and Kendall Jones, who were challenging the state's use of dismissed felony convictions to prohibit firearm ownership. The decision emphasizes that once a conviction is vacated, individuals should not face penalties based on it, restoring their rights.

Tags

Second Amendment
California Gun Law
Federal Injunction
Vacated Felony Conviction
Non-Violent Felony
Rob Bonta
Allison Mendoza
Paul McKinley
Stewart
Kendall Jones
Firearms Policy Coalition
Christopher Hoffman
Chad Orin
Jennifer SBA
Bruen Decision

Quick Summary

A California federal judge issued a permanent injunction, preventing the state from denying Second Amendment rights to individuals with non-violent felony convictions from other states that have been vacated or nullified. This ruling specifically protects plaintiffs whose past felony convictions were dismissed, restoring their right to own firearms.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Hope for 2A Rights
  2. 00:13Historical Context of Gun Laws
  3. 00:18Irresponsible Individuals and Firearm Carry
  4. 00:27New California Federal Judge Ruling Announced
  5. 00:31Judge Rules in Favor of Plaintiffs
  6. 00:37Permanent Injunction Against California
  7. 00:40Stopping Denial of Rights for Vacated Felonies
  8. 00:50Specific Relief for Plaintiffs McKinley, Stewart, Jones
  9. 00:58Defendants: Rob Bonta and Allison Mendoza
  10. 01:05Court Order Against Prohibiting Firearm Ownership
  11. 01:16Basis of Denial: Past Felony Convictions
  12. 01:23Specific Penal Codes Targeted: 29800 and 30305
  13. 01:35Critique of Legal Analysis and Outcomes
  14. 01:41Renewed Hope and Federal Gun Law Bills
  15. 01:59Tragedies and Official Action
  16. 02:06Proactive Prevention and Future Possibilities
  17. 02:11Stewart's Vacated 1976 Felony Conviction
  18. 02:20Court Stops Penal Codes Against Kendall Jones
  19. 02:30Jones' Vacated 1980 Felony Conviction
  20. 02:38Denial of Certificate of Eligibility (26710)
  21. 02:47Ensuring Rights Are Not Infringed
  22. 02:55California Cannot Use Dismissed Convictions
  23. 03:00Court Oversight of Order Enforcement
  24. 03:07Gun Violence as America's Disease
  25. 03:12Changing Trajectory and Ending Epidemic
  26. 03:17Impact of Gun Violence on American Lives
  27. 03:22Common Sense Data-Driven Gun Laws
  28. 03:29Significant Legal Implications of the Ruling
  29. 03:32Vacated Convictions and Penalties
  30. 03:42Restoring Individual Rights and Status
  31. 03:47Specific Naming of Defendants and Subordinates
  32. 03:55Ensuring Compliance Across Departments
  33. 04:03Permanent Order and Lasting Solution
  34. 04:08Court Retaining Jurisdiction
  35. 04:13Ongoing Protection of Rights
  36. 04:21Safety in Communities Needs to Be Different
  37. 04:25Tailored Strategies for Peace and Safety
  38. 04:29Fighting for Californian Safety
  39. 04:32Common Sense Steps to Save Lives
  40. 04:37Unique Tragedy and Epidemic of Gun Violence
  41. 04:41Frequency of Gun Violence Tragedies in US
  42. 04:46Strengthening Concealed Carry Weapon Laws
  43. 04:55Federal Government Must Act
  44. 05:00Waiting for Action to Keep Americans Safe
  45. 05:05San Diego Federal Lawsuit
  46. 05:08Non-Profit Advocating for Gun Rights
  47. 05:12Individuals from PA, ID, NM File Lawsuit
  48. 05:17Challenging California's Non-Resident Firearm Ban
  49. 05:25Lawsuit Claims Violation of 2nd and 14th Amendments
  50. 05:31Regulation Unconstitutionally Restrictive
  51. 05:36Stopping Plaintiffs with Concealed Carry Permits
  52. 05:45Comparison to First and Fourth Amendment Rights
  53. 05:57Second Amendment Rights Across State Lines
  54. 06:07No Response from Attorney General's Office
  55. 06:15Historical Defense of California Gun Regulations
  56. 06:20California's Strong Gun Safety Laws
  57. 06:22Reliance on Data and Evidence
  58. 06:28Low Firearm Mortality Rates Due to Strong Laws
  59. 06:32Past High Firearm Mortality Rates
  60. 06:36Strengthening Gun Laws Over Decades
  61. 06:38Concerns About CCW Discretion and Crime
  62. 06:47Data on CCW Holders Committing Crimes
  63. 06:53Legal Battle Focused on San Diego
  64. 06:56Impact on Plaintiffs Barred from Bringing Firearms
  65. 07:04Narrow Exception for Out-of-State Business Owners
  66. 07:14Plaintiff Christopher Hoffman's History
  67. 07:22Hoffman's Concealed Carry Licenses in San Diego
  68. 07:30Hoffman's Frequent Visits and Self-Defense Concerns
  69. 07:37Other Plaintiffs: Chad Orin and Jennifer SBA
  70. 07:46Lawsuit Participants: Individuals and FPC
  71. 07:50Brandon Combs: Firearms Policy Coalition
  72. 07:54Right to Bear Arms Doesn't End at Border
  73. 08:01Restoring Liberty in California
  74. 08:05Eliminating Unconstitutional Ban
  75. 08:08Federal Court in San Diego Challenges
  76. 08:11California's Stringent Arm Rules
  77. 08:16Recent Lawsuit as Latest Challenge
  78. 08:19Losses Due to Gun Violence
  79. 08:25Bruen Decision Impact
  80. 08:29Bruen Compliant Approach
  81. 08:32Irresponsible Individuals and Concealed Carry
  82. 08:36Court Cases and Sensitive Places
  83. 08:38Concealed Carry in Sensitive Places
  84. 08:42Evaluations for CCW Permits
  85. 08:47Facts and Likelihood of Victimization
  86. 08:50Lower Firearm Mortality Rates in States with Stronger Laws
  87. 09:04State Prohibitions on Assault Rifles and Magazines
  88. 09:09Frequent Arm Transactions and Switchblades
  89. 09:13Judge Roger Benitez's Decisions
  90. 09:17Repeated Overturning of California Firearms Laws
  91. 09:21Judge Benitez Nicknamed 'St. Benitez'
  92. 09:27San Diego as a Location for Challenges
  93. 09:32Random Case Assignment
  94. 09:37Local Court Rule for Similar Matters
  95. 09:42Bringing Weapons Challenges to Benitez's Courtroom
  96. 09:45Judge Shopping Scandal
  97. 09:50Local Court Revised Regulation
  98. 09:53Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell
  99. 09:55Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer
  100. 09:58Legislation to Alter Case Assignment System
  101. 10:05US Judicial Conference New Guidelines
  102. 10:07Random Assignment of Constitutional Issues
  103. 10:10National Importance of Cases
  104. 10:15District Judge Kathy Benigno Appointed
  105. 10:18Random Assignment to Hear Non-Resident Ban Case
  106. 10:22California Non-Resident Firearm Ban
  107. 10:25US Supreme Court's Bruen Decision
  108. 10:27New Standard for Evaluating Arm Restrictions
  109. 10:33Second Amendment Rights Groups Success
  110. 10:35Last Two Years of Court Successes
  111. 10:42Rights Advocates Want Dupe in San Diego Lawsuits
  112. 10:45Supreme Court's Firearms Decision
  113. 10:50Bruen Ruling Impact on Courts
  114. 10:52Debating Constitutionality of Arm Control Measures
  115. 10:57Second Amendment's Plain Guarantee
  116. 11:01Consistent with Historical Tradition of Arm Regulation
  117. 11:06Benitez and Other Federal Courts in San Diego
  118. 11:09Reasoning Based on Bruen
  119. 11:12Repealed Assault Weapons Bans
  120. 11:14Billy Club Bans
  121. 11:17Ammunition Purchase Background Checks
  122. 11:19Bans on Specific Unsafe Pistols
  123. 11:22Previous Year's California Legislation
  124. 11:24Decisions Currently Being Appealed
  125. 11:27Ninth US Circuit Court of Appeals
  126. 11:29Gun Violence Crisis
  127. 11:33Choice to Lean In and Save Lives
  128. 11:38California's Approach: Built Different
  129. 11:41States Putting Heads in the Sand
  130. 11:46Act and Push Forward
  131. 11:48California's Unique Stance
  132. 11:51Not Accepting the Unacceptable
  133. 11:54Constitutionally Compliant Actions
  134. 11:56Conclusion of Video

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the recent California federal judge ruling regarding Second Amendment rights?

A California federal judge issued a permanent injunction, preventing the state from denying Second Amendment rights to individuals with non-violent felony convictions from other states that have been vacated or nullified. This ruling specifically protects plaintiffs whose past felony convictions were dismissed, restoring their right to own firearms.

Who are the key figures and defendants in the California gun law lawsuit?

The lawsuit involves plaintiffs Paul McKinley, Stewart, and Kendall Jones, who sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta and Allison Mendoza, Director of the California Department of Justice Bureau of Firearms. The court's order directly impacts these state officials and their associates.

What specific California Penal Codes were addressed in the ruling concerning vacated felony convictions?

The court order prevents the use of California Penal Codes 29800 and 30305 to deny firearm rights to individuals like Paul McKinley, Stewart, and Kendall Jones, whose past felony convictions were later dismissed or vacated. This ruling clarifies that these codes cannot be used to prohibit firearm ownership based on such convictions.

What are the broader implications of the ruling on vacated convictions and firearm rights?

The ruling emphasizes that once a conviction is dismissed or vacated, individuals should not face penalties or restrictions based on it. This principle is crucial for restoring an individual's rights and status, ensuring that past, invalidated convictions do not permanently bar them from exercising their Second Amendment rights.

Related Articles

All Articles →
Common Use: The Math, the Law, and the 24 Million AR-15s in American Hands
Explainer20 min read

Common Use: The Math, the Law, and the 24 Million AR-15s in American Hands

Related News

All News →

SAF LAUNCHES NEW NATIONAL TV AD CAMPAIGN - Second Amendment Foundation

Google News - Second Amendment·

Fearing expanding gun rights, anti-gun group creates absurd concealed-carry policy - Second Amendment Foundation

Google News - Concealed Carry·

Lindsey Graham urges US, Israel to arm Iranian civilians in 'Second Amendment solution' to topple regime - Fox News

Google News - Second Amendment·

SILENCER SHOP RENEWS CORPORATE PARTNER COMMITMENT AT PLATINUM LEVEL - Second Amendment Foundation

Google News - Second Amendment·

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

Developing: California Mag Ban Duncan v. Bonta In Trouble
Developing: California Mag Ban Duncan v. Bonta In Trouble

The video discusses the critical status of the Duncan v. Bonta magazine capacity ban challenge before the Supreme Court. Recent developments, including the en banc rehearing granted in Benson v. United States (DC's magazine ban case) and a letter from California AG Rob Bonta to the Supreme Court, have significantly complicated Duncan's chances of being accepted for review. The DC case's reversal means a key supporting precedent for Duncan has been vacated, and Bonta's letter aims to further dissuade the Supreme Court from taking up Duncan.

Duncan v. Bonta
Magazine Capacity Ban
Channel:Copper Jacket TV
Category:2nd Amendment & Law
Date: Apr 24, 2026
Duration: 6:15
The Current Strategy to End the NFA with $0 Tax Stamps
The Current Strategy to End the NFA with $0 Tax Stamps

This video analyzes the current strategy to challenge the National Firearms Act (NFA) by leveraging recent legal precedents and shifting NFA registration numbers. It discusses the historical context of NFA challenges, starting with the Miller decision and progressing through Heller and Bruen, emphasizing the 'common use' doctrine. The speaker highlights the unprecedented surge in NFA item registrations in early 2024, suggesting this volume, combined with the removal of tax stamps, weakens the legal basis for the NFA registry.

NFA
ATF
Channel:The VSO Gun Channel
Category:2nd Amendment & Law
Date: Apr 23, 2026
Duration: 13:05
Bad News from SCOTUS
Bad News from SCOTUS

This video discusses the Supreme Court's denial of certiorari in Gardner v. Maryland, a case that could have provided clarification on interstate firearm reciprocity. The hosts explain the details of Eva Marie Gardner's case, where she was convicted in Maryland for possessing a handgun despite being licensed in Virginia and encountering an aggressive driver. They analyze Maryland's legal arguments and the potential implications of the Supreme Court's decision, particularly concerning the application of the Bruen decision to interstate travel and the historical analysis of firearm regulations.

SCOTUS
Second Amendment
Channel:Armed Attorneys
Category:2nd Amendment & Law
Date: Apr 22, 2026
Duration: 11:04
EXPOSED: Congress Demands DOJ Stop Gun Enforcement
EXPOSED: Congress Demands DOJ Stop Gun Enforcement

This video details a letter from 33 members of Congress to President Trump, outlining a roadmap to cease enforcement of Biden-era gun regulations and reform the ATF. It emphasizes the need for the Department of Justice to stop defending unconstitutional gun laws and to address the ATF's culture and funding. The core message is that the fight for Second Amendment rights hinges on stopping the enforcement of unconstitutional laws, not just passing new ones.

DOJ
ATF
Channel:Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News
Category:2nd Amendment & Law
Date: Apr 22, 2026
Duration: 13:43
HUGE BREAKING NEWS! MAJOR 2A SUPREME COURT DECISION OUT NOW!
HUGE BREAKING NEWS! MAJOR 2A SUPREME COURT DECISION OUT NOW!

This video discusses the US Supreme Court's denial of cert in two significant Second Amendment cases: Eva Gardner v. Maryland and George Peterson v. United States. While both cases were unfortunately turned down, the speaker, Mark Smith, a constitutional attorney and Second Amendment advocate, speculates on potential future positive outcomes. He suggests the court may be clearing the docket to focus on upcoming cases concerning AR-15 bans, magazine capacity limits, and the rights of young adults (18-20 years old).

Supreme Court
Second Amendment
Channel:The Four Boxes Diner
Category:2nd Amendment & Law
Date: Apr 20, 2026
Duration: 12:27
Huge: Supreme Court Considers 2 New Major 2nd Amendment Cases
Huge: Supreme Court Considers 2 New Major 2nd Amendment Cases

The Supreme Court is considering seven major Second Amendment challenges, including four previously discussed cases (Duncan v. Bont, Gator v. Washington, Vera Montes v. Cook County, NGRV v. Lamont) and two new ones. Peterson v. United States challenges the NFA's taxation and registration scheme for firearms, particularly suppressors, arguing it violates the Second Amendment under the Bruen standard. Gardner v. Maryland addresses the Second Amendment rights of an interstate traveler carrying a handgun in self-defense when their out-of-state permit is not recognized by Maryland.

Supreme Court
Second Amendment
Channel:Copper Jacket TV
Category:2nd Amendment & Law
Date: Apr 18, 2026
Duration: 8:12

More from Best Iron

View all →
This 410 Revolver Shotgun Is The BEST of 2023
This 410 Revolver Shotgun Is The BEST of 2023

This review highlights several versatile firearms capable of firing both .410 shells and other handgun calibers. The Taurus Judge Public Defender and Smith & Wesson Governor offer .45 Colt compatibility, while the Raging Judge adds .454 Casull. For a unique shotgun experience, the DP-12 provides a double-barrel, bullpup design. The BFR and Bond Arms Derringer are also noted for their robust build and caliber versatility.

410 Revolver Shotgun
Shotgun
Channel:Best Iron
Category:Reviews
Date: Jun 23, 2023
Duration: 25:08
TOP 10 Best Handguns Under $300 BUILD For 2024! Review
TOP 10 Best Handguns Under $300 BUILD For 2024! Review

This video provides an expert review of the top 10 best handguns available for under $300 in 2024. The instructor highlights budget-friendly options that do not compromise on reliability, covering models from Taurus, Ruger, Smith & Wesson, Canik, and more. Specific details on capacity, caliber, and performance in endurance tests are discussed, offering valuable insights for budget-conscious firearm owners.

Taurus G2C
Ruger Security-9
Channel:Best Iron
Category:Reviews
Date: May 16, 2022
Duration: 8:19
TOP 5 Best 9mm Carbines Under $400 BUILD In 2024 REVIEW
TOP 5 Best 9mm Carbines Under $400 BUILD In 2024 REVIEW

This video reviews the top 5 best 9mm carbines under $400, highlighting their features, price points, and value. The expert instructor emphasizes affordability and functionality for home defense and range use. Key models discussed include the Kel-Tec Sub 2000, Hi-Point 995TS, Chiappa M1-9, Ruger PC Carbine, and PSA Gen4 AR-9, with a focus on magazine compatibility and portability.

9mm Carbine
Kel-Tec Sub 2000
Channel:Best Iron
Category:Reviews
Date: May 19, 2022
Duration: 8:07
Keanu Reeves Shows His TOP 8 Private Gun Collection
Keanu Reeves Shows His TOP 8 Private Gun Collection

This entry details the firearms and training methodologies showcased in the context of the John Wick film series, highlighting Keanu Reeves' dedication and the specific firearms used. It draws upon the expertise of instructors like Taran Butler, emphasizing realistic gun handling and cinematic techniques. The content covers specific models from Heckler & Koch, Benelli, Taran Tactical Innovations, STI, SIG Sauer, Kel-Tec, and Desert Tactical Arms, offering insights into their tactical relevance and movie portrayal.

John Wick
Keanu Reeves
Channel:Best Iron
Category:Tactical & Gear
Date: Apr 19, 2023
Duration: 12:18
Find an FFL
Licensed dealers in your area