Difference Between May-Issue and Shall-Issue Concealed Carry States...

Published on October 28, 2023
Duration: 2:48

This video explains the fundamental difference between 'May-Issue' and 'Shall-Issue' concealed carry license states, highlighting the impact of the Supreme Court's Bruen decision. It clarifies that 'May-Issue' states allowed subjective denial of licenses, while 'Shall-Issue' states mandate issuance if objective criteria are met. The speaker notes a transition towards 'Shall-Issue' nationwide but acknowledges ongoing challenges in some states.

Quick Summary

The key difference between May-Issue and Shall-Issue concealed carry states lies in the discretion of the issuing authority. 'May-Issue' allowed subjective denials, while 'Shall-Issue' mandates issuance if objective criteria are met. The Supreme Court's Bruen decision in June 2022 effectively ended 'May-Issue' states nationwide.

Chapters

  1. 00:02Intro: May-Issue vs. Shall-Issue
  2. 00:14Bruen Decision Ends May-Issue
  3. 00:25What Was May-Issue?
  4. 00:54The Shall-Issue Standard
  5. 01:15License Issuance Timeframes
  6. 01:34Ongoing State Challenges
  7. 01:55Theoretical vs. Practical Reality
  8. 02:14Giveaway Announcement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between May-Issue and Shall-Issue concealed carry states?

In 'May-Issue' states, authorities could deny a concealed carry license even if objective criteria were met, often for subjective reasons. In 'Shall-Issue' states, licenses must be granted if the applicant meets all objective requirements, like age and legal eligibility.

How did the Bruen decision affect concealed carry laws?

The Supreme Court's Bruen decision in June 2022 eliminated the 'May-Issue' system. It mandated that all states must operate under a 'Shall-Issue' framework, meaning licenses should be issued to those who meet objective criteria.

Are all states now fully Shall-Issue after the Bruen decision?

While the Bruen decision mandates a 'Shall-Issue' system, some states are still implementing broad or potentially discretionary requirements, like social media checks, which can complicate the process and may not fully align with the spirit of the ruling.

What are the typical objective criteria for a Shall-Issue concealed carry license?

Common objective criteria for obtaining a concealed carry license in 'Shall-Issue' states include meeting a minimum age requirement, not being a prohibited possessor under federal or state law, and often being a citizen of the United States.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from USCCA

View all →