Firearms Manufactures & Distributors Should Be Held Accountable for Gun Crimes

Published on July 31, 2017
Duration: 12:27

This video argues against holding gun manufacturers and dealers liable for crimes committed with firearms, drawing parallels to other industries. The speaker contends that current legal frameworks, including background checks, already place liability on individuals who misuse firearms illegally. The argument posits that legal sales to individuals permitted by law do not create liability for the seller, unless the sale itself is illegal. The speaker also critiques the analogy of holding gun sellers responsible for criminal misuse, comparing it to holding liquor stores responsible for DUIs.

Quick Summary

Gun manufacturers and dealers are generally not liable for crimes committed with firearms if they sell legally to individuals permitted by law. Liability typically arises only if the sale itself is illegal or if the product is defective, similar to other industries. Background checks help dealers fulfill legal obligations and mitigate liability for subsequent misuse.

Chapters

  1. 00:11Introduction and Personal Anecdote
  2. 00:51Initial Argument: Holding Gun Shops Accountable
  3. 01:13Counter-Argument: DUI Analogy and Bar Liability
  4. 02:01Firearms Analogy vs. Bar Liability
  5. 02:10Legality of Gun Sales and Background Checks
  6. 03:10Revised Analogy: Sober Buyer, Illegal Use
  7. 04:07Comparing Gun Sales to Other Retail
  8. 04:34Dealers Don't Judge Character
  9. 05:05Far-Fetched Scenarios for Liability
  10. 05:34Are Guns Just Created to Kill?
  11. 06:36Justification for Special Protection Claims
  12. 06:46Debunking 'Special Protection' Claims
  13. 07:39Targeting Businesses Through Lawsuits
  14. 08:11Judicial and Political Response to Lawsuits
  15. 08:37Manufacturer Liability: Defective Products
  16. 09:09Conclusion on Special Protection
  17. 09:16Importance of Applicable Analogies
  18. 09:33Summary of Legal Sales and Liability
  19. 10:00Protection Against Frivolous Lawsuits
  20. 10:30Final Argument on Manufacturer Responsibility

Frequently Asked Questions

Are gun manufacturers and dealers liable for crimes committed with their products?

Generally, no. Gun manufacturers and dealers are not liable for criminal misuse of firearms if they sell legally to individuals permitted by law. Liability typically arises only if the sale itself is illegal or if the product is defective, similar to other industries.

How do background checks affect gun dealer liability?

Background checks, provided by federal and state agencies, are designed to vet potential buyers. By adhering to these checks and selling only to individuals cleared by the system, dealers fulfill their legal obligation and mitigate their liability for subsequent misuse.

Is the analogy of a bartender serving a drunk driver applicable to gun sales?

No, the speaker argues this analogy is flawed. Serving an intoxicated person is an illegal act, whereas selling a firearm to a person legally permitted to own one is a legal transaction. Liability in the bar scenario stems from the illegal act of over-serving.

Do gun manufacturers have special legal protections?

The speaker contends that gun manufacturers and dealers are protected against frivolous lawsuits, not from liability for defective products or illegal sales. This protection is likened to hate crime laws, shielding targeted businesses from baseless litigation.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →