Florida Stand Your Ground Law Ruled Unconstitutional

This video discusses a recent ruling by Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Milton Hiers that declared an amendment to Florida's Stand Your Ground law unconstitutional. The amendment, signed by Governor Rick Scott and backed by the NRA, shifted the burden of proof back to the prosecution, a change the judge argued should have originated from the Florida Supreme Court. The video contrasts this with the 2015 shift that placed the burden on defendants, stemming from the George Zimmerman/Trayvon Martin case.

Quick Summary

Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Milton Hiers ruled an amendment to Florida's Stand Your Ground law unconstitutional. This amendment, backed by the NRA and signed by Governor Rick Scott, shifted the burden of proof back to the prosecution, a change the judge argued should have originated from the Florida Supreme Court.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Introduction & Channel Welcome
  2. 00:13Florida Stand Your Ground Law Amendment
  3. 00:30Burden of Proof Shift Explained
  4. 00:57Reactions to the Amendment
  5. 01:23Judge Hiers' Ruling
  6. 01:52History of Florida's Stand Your Ground Law
  7. 02:30Original Law Provisions
  8. 03:00Impact of Zimmerman/Martin Case
  9. 03:17Constitutional Principle of Innocence
  10. 03:46Concluding Remarks & Independence Day

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the recent ruling regarding Florida's Stand Your Ground law?

Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Milton Hiers ruled an amendment to Florida's Stand Your Ground law unconstitutional. This amendment had shifted the burden of proof back to the prosecution, a change the judge felt should have been initiated by the Florida Supreme Court.

How did the 2015 change to Florida's Stand Your Ground law affect the burden of proof?

In 2015, Florida law was amended to place the burden of proving innocence on the defendant in Stand Your Ground cases. This reversed the long-standing legal principle of 'innocent until proven guilty' for those invoking the law.

What did Florida's original Stand Your Ground law (2005) permit?

The 2005 Florida Stand Your Ground law allowed individuals to use deadly force if they reasonably believed they faced imminent death or great bodily harm, without a legal duty to retreat from the situation.

Why was the recent amendment to Florida's Stand Your Ground law controversial?

The amendment was controversial because it shifted the burden of proof back to the prosecution. Critics argued this was a legislative overreach, with Judge Hiers stating such a change should originate from the Florida Supreme Court.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

View all →