Kicked Out For Owning Guns | Leyla Pirnie

Published on December 5, 2018
Duration: 7:55

This video details the case of Leyla Pirnie, a Harvard graduate student evicted from her Massachusetts apartment due to her legal gun ownership. It highlights the conflict between a tenant's right to own firearms and roommates' claims of discomfort and lack of 'quiet enjoyment.' The narrative critically examines the landlord's actions, the roommates' demands exceeding state law, and the legal complexities involved in such disputes, emphasizing the importance of understanding tenant rights and firearm regulations.

Quick Summary

A Harvard student, Leyla Pirnie, faced eviction in Massachusetts for legally owning firearms. Her roommates' demands for storage exceeded state law, and the landlord cited 'differences in philosophy.' Legal experts suggest landlords typically need a lease violation to evict, not just roommate discomfort.

Chapters

  1. 00:03Student Faces Eviction for Gun Ownership
  2. 00:26Roommates' Ultimatum to Leyla
  3. 00:32Roommates Illegally Search Room
  4. 00:50Roommates Admit to Illegal Search
  5. 01:12Prejudice Led to Room Search
  6. 01:29Fear-Driven Invasion of Privacy
  7. 01:51Landlord's Eviction Notice
  8. 01:59Roommates Complain to Landlord
  9. 02:22Roommates Demand Quiet Enjoyment
  10. 02:38Excessive Storage Demands
  11. 03:16Disbelief in License, More Demands
  12. 03:30Police Confirm Legal Compliance
  13. 03:47Massachusetts Grace Period Applies
  14. 04:06Landlord's Eviction Based on 'Philosophy'
  15. 04:22Landlord's Coercive Offer
  16. 04:56Landlord's Actions Highly Questionable
  17. 06:01Eviction for 'Hurt Feelings'
  18. 06:30Leyla's Motivation and Stance
  19. 06:53Leyla Lawyers Up
  20. 07:23Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

Can roommates legally force you to remove your firearms from a shared apartment?

Generally, roommates cannot force you to remove legally owned firearms unless your lease agreement explicitly prohibits them or your presence with firearms violates specific local ordinances. Demands exceeding legal storage requirements are often considered unreasonable.

What is the 'quiet enjoyment' clause in a lease, and how does it apply to gun ownership?

Quiet enjoyment ensures a tenant's right to peaceful possession of their rental property. While roommates can claim discomfort, using this clause to ban legal firearm ownership typically requires demonstrating a tangible disturbance, not just subjective anxiety.

Can a landlord evict a tenant for owning guns if the lease doesn't prohibit it?

In most jurisdictions, a landlord cannot evict a tenant for legally owning firearms if the lease agreement does not contain a specific prohibition. Eviction usually requires a violation of lease terms or illegal activity.

What are the firearm storage laws in Massachusetts for legal owners?

Massachusetts law requires firearms to be stored securely, often with trigger locks or in safes, and unloaded when not in use. However, specific demands from roommates may exceed these baseline legal requirements.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Liberty Doll

View all →