Man Denied Gun Permit Over Driving Record

Published on November 13, 2024
Duration: 9:05

This video details the case of Leonard Mirabal, who was denied a concealed carry permit in Carlstadt, New Jersey, twice due to his non-criminal driving record and alleged 'lack of good temperament.' The report highlights the subjective nature of New Jersey's permitting process, which appears to contradict the spirit of the Bruen decision. Mirabal's eventual success in obtaining both a job-specific and an unrestricted carry permit from the New Jersey State Police underscores the inconsistencies and potential overreach of local authorities.

Quick Summary

Leonard Mirabal was denied a concealed carry permit in New Jersey twice due to his non-criminal driving record and perceived 'lack of good temperament.' Despite these local denials, he was eventually approved for both a job-specific and an unrestricted carry permit by the New Jersey State Police, highlighting potential inconsistencies in state-level versus local permitting processes.

Chapters

  1. 00:00NJ Gun Permit Scandal & Mirabal's Case
  2. 00:32Introduction to Leonard Mirabal's Story
  3. 01:49First Denial: Driving Record Cited
  4. 02:32Non-Criminal Driving Record Issue
  5. 03:18Subjective Standards vs. Bruen
  6. 03:22Communication Issues & Application Errors
  7. 04:33Second Application for Carry Permit
  8. 04:52Detective Wong's Inquiry on Driving History
  9. 05:40Second Denial Letter & Statute Cited
  10. 06:24Wong's Personal Opinion on Attitude
  11. 06:33Questioning Carlstadt Police & Officials
  12. 07:08Seeking Comment from Attorney General
  13. 07:20Applying Directly to NJ State Police
  14. 07:30Job-Specific Permit Approved
  15. 07:43Unrestricted Permit Approved by State Police
  16. 08:07Conclusion: Subjective Standards & Accountability

Frequently Asked Questions

Why was Leonard Mirabal denied a gun permit in New Jersey?

Leonard Mirabal was denied a concealed carry permit twice in Carlstadt, New Jersey. The initial denial cited his 'extensive driving history record,' including a revoked commercial driver's license, and a perceived 'lack of good temperament.' These reasons were deemed insufficient by the New Jersey State Police in subsequent applications.

Can a non-criminal driving record prevent you from getting a gun permit in New Jersey?

While New Jersey law allows permit denial if an applicant is deemed a danger to public safety, using a non-criminal driving record as the sole basis for denial has been questioned. Mirabal's case demonstrates that such denials can occur, but he was eventually approved by the State Police without expunging his driving record.

Did the Bruen decision affect New Jersey's gun permit process?

The video suggests that New Jersey's continued use of subjective standards for gun permits, as seen in Mirabal's case, may be in conflict with the Supreme Court's Bruen decision. The decision aimed to move away from 'good cause' or subjective 'good temperament' requirements for carry permits.

How did Leonard Mirabal eventually get a gun permit in New Jersey?

After being denied by local Carlstadt police, Leonard Mirabal applied directly to a New Jersey State Police barracks for a permit related to his job. This permit was approved quickly. He then applied for and received an unrestricted permit to carry from the State Police, bypassing the issues encountered locally.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Liberty Doll

View all →