National Handgun Bans in Canada Won't Make A Difference

Published on June 20, 2022
Duration: 6:53

Colion Noir, an expert firearms instructor, critically analyzes Canada's national handgun ban, arguing it's ineffective against criminals who acquire firearms illegally. He supports his claims with data from a US Department of Justice report on criminal gun sources and statistics on illegal firearms in the UK and Australia. Noir emphasizes that focusing on legal gun owners is misguided and that the Second Amendment is crucial for citizen empowerment and protection against potential government overreach.

Quick Summary

Colion Noir argues Canada's national handgun ban is ineffective, citing a US DOJ report showing criminals acquire guns illegally (street, gifts, theft) not from legal sources. He notes rising illegal firearms in the UK and Australia despite strict laws, emphasizing the Second Amendment's role in citizen empowerment and limiting government overreach.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Canadian Handgun Ban Debate Intro
  2. 00:05Police Chiefs Reject Ban
  3. 00:18Illegal Handgun Possession
  4. 00:40Handgun-Free Zones Ineffective
  5. 01:08Illegality Won't Stop Criminals
  6. 01:22Existing Laws Address Gun Theft
  7. 01:58Canada's 2022 Handgun Ban
  8. 02:15Criminals Bypass Legal Pathways
  9. 02:56US DOJ Report: Criminal Gun Sources
  10. 03:20Illicit Gun Acquisition Channels
  11. 03:39UK's Rising Illegal Firearms
  12. 04:26Australia's Illegal Gun Inventory
  13. 04:43Trust Police Over Politicians
  14. 05:00Government Monopoly on Violence
  15. 05:25Respect for Armed Population
  16. 05:49COVID Lockdowns & Gun Ownership
  17. 06:14Second Amendment Empowers Citizens

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are national handgun bans in Canada considered ineffective?

National handgun bans in Canada are considered ineffective because criminals obtain firearms through illegal channels, not by purchasing legally. Data shows a very low percentage of criminals acquire guns from retail sources, with most coming from the street, gifts, or theft. Therefore, new laws targeting legal owners do not impact criminal activity.

What does the US Department of Justice report say about how criminals obtain firearms?

A 2019 US Department of Justice report, using 2016 data, found that less than 2% of prisoners obtained firearms from retail sources. The majority acquired guns illegally: 43% from the street/underground market, 25% from family/friends, 6% stolen, and 7% found at crime scenes.

How do illegal firearms compare in the UK and Australia despite strict gun control?

Despite strict gun control, the UK has seen a quadrupling of illegal firearm confiscations over three years, indicating rising illegal gun availability. Australia, also with strict laws, is estimated to have over 260,000 illegal firearms in circulation, showing the persistent challenge of illicit gun ownership.

What is the significance of the Second Amendment in the context of gun control debates?

The Second Amendment is presented as a fundamental right empowering US citizens for self-protection and serving as a crucial check on government power. It suggests that governments show more respect for an armed populace, and its presence influenced government caution during COVID-19 lockdowns.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Colion Noir

View all →