NRA News at the United Nations Arms Trade Treaty Negotiations: Allen Youngman

Published on July 26, 2012
Duration: 9:12

Allen Youngman, representing military small arms manufacturers, discusses concerns regarding the UN Arms Trade Treaty draft. He highlights the lack of definition for 'transfer,' which could encompass civilian sales and ownership, directly impacting Second Amendment rights. The treaty's inclusion of small arms and light weapons, potentially including hunting shotguns and handguns, is a significant concern, as proponents claim it's not about civilian gun control while simultaneously resisting language to exempt civilian firearms.

Quick Summary

The UN Arms Trade Treaty draft raises concerns due to its undefined term 'transfer,' which could extend to civilian firearm sales and ownership, impacting Second Amendment rights. Despite claims of not targeting civilian gun control, explicit exemptions for civilian firearms are resisted, and the broad definition of 'small arms' includes common civilian firearms.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Treaty Draft Reaction
  2. 00:21Industry Concerns
  3. 00:37Lack of Definition: 'Transfer'
  4. 01:07Second Amendment Implications
  5. 02:04Civilian Ownership in Treaty Draft
  6. 02:19Small Arms and Light Weapons Scope
  7. 03:05Industry Perspective on Negotiations
  8. 03:23US Export Controls
  9. 04:01Ammunition and Munitions
  10. 04:36Complexity of Regulation
  11. 05:04Erosion of Ownership
  12. 05:27US Delegation Efforts
  13. 06:00Treaty Prospects and Timeline
  14. 07:07American Constitutional Rights
  15. 08:05Importance of Industry Presence
  16. 08:20Legitimate Industry Operations
  17. 08:54Making a Difference

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary concern regarding the UN Arms Trade Treaty draft?

The main concern is the lack of definition for 'transfer,' which could be interpreted to include civilian firearm sales and ownership, potentially impacting Second Amendment rights in the US. Proponents claim it's not about civilian gun control, but resist explicit exemptions.

How does the UN Arms Trade Treaty define 'small arms and light weapons'?

The treaty's definition is broad and can encompass civilian firearms such as hunting shotguns, handguns used for home defense, and .22 rifles. This inclusion is a significant point of contention for those concerned about civilian gun ownership.

What is the impact of US export controls on the firearms industry?

US firearm exports are heavily scrutinized and controlled by the government. This creates a competitive disadvantage against international companies whose governments have less stringent export licensing standards, making it harder for US manufacturers to compete globally.

Why is the presence of industry organizations at the UN treaty negotiations important?

Industry organizations like those representing small arms manufacturers are crucial for explaining the complexities of civilian firearm ownership and the US constitutional rights to international delegates who may not understand these concepts, potentially influencing treaty language.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →