So They Want To Redo the 1st and 2nd Amendments...

Published on December 29, 2021
Duration: 8:59

This video discusses a proposal by scholar Mary Anne Franks, published in the Boston Globe, to amend the First and Second Amendments of the U.S. Constitution. Franks argues for a reinterpretation that emphasizes collective good over individualistic interpretations, suggesting changes to free speech regulations and proposing a new amendment focused on bodily autonomy and public safety. The host strongly refutes these ideas, asserting the unalienable nature of rights and the clarity of the Second Amendment.

Quick Summary

Scholar Mary Anne Franks has proposed significant changes to the First and Second Amendments, aiming to prioritize collective good and bodily autonomy. The host of Guns & Gadgets strongly refutes these ideas, asserting that rights are unalienable and government control over them is unacceptable.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Intro: Scholar Proposes Changing Amendments
  2. 00:21Sponsor: Sonoran Desert Institute
  3. 01:05Boston Globe Article & Mary Anne Franks
  4. 01:50Franks' Critique of First & Second Amendments
  5. 03:08Proposed Changes to First Amendment
  6. 04:44Proposed Changes to Second Amendment
  7. 05:43Mary Anne Franks' Background
  8. 06:03Host's Rebuttal: Rights Are Unalienable
  9. 06:39Host's Rebuttal: Clarity of Second Amendment
  10. 07:15Host's Stance on Self-Defense
  11. 07:33Host's View: Beyond Self-Defense
  12. 08:04Constitutional Amendment Process
  13. 08:23Call to Action & Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is proposing changes to the First and Second Amendments?

A leftist scholar named Mary Anne Franks, a distinguished scholar at the University of Miami School of Law, has proposed significant changes to the First and Second Amendments of the U.S. Constitution, as published in the Boston Globe.

What are Mary Anne Franks' main arguments for changing the First Amendment?

Franks suggests revising the First Amendment to explicitly acknowledge individual rights within the framework of domestic tranquility and general welfare. This could allow for campaign finance reform and make the separation of church and state explicit.

What are Mary Anne Franks' proposed changes to the Second Amendment?

Franks proposes an amendment that guarantees bodily autonomy, including the right to defend against unlawful force and self-determination in reproductive matters. The government would be obligated to take reasonable measures to protect public health and safety.

What is the host's primary objection to these proposed amendments?

The host argues that rights are unalienable and pre-existing, not granted by the government. He criticizes Franks' proposals for suggesting government control over these fundamental rights and emphasizes the clarity and non-negotiable nature of the Second Amendment.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

View all →