Supreme Court 6-3 Concealed Carry Decision Up For Reconsideration In New Case!!!

Published on October 26, 2022
Duration: 9:37

This video, presented by Anthony Miranda, a licensed attorney and staff attorney with the Firearms Policy Coalition, discusses the Baldi v. City of New York concealed carry case before the Supreme Court. It analyzes the historical 'proper cause' standard for concealed carry permits in New York, the Supreme Court's decision in NYSRPA v. Bruin which struck down such standards, and the subsequent legislative changes in New York with the CCIA. The discussion focuses on whether the Supreme Court will reconsider the Baldi case in light of Bruin, particularly concerning a police officer's denied renewal for an unrestricted concealed carry permit.

Quick Summary

The Baldi v. City of New York case is before the Supreme Court, challenging the denial of an unrestricted concealed carry permit for a police officer. This case examines New York's past 'proper cause' standard and current laws like the CCIA, following the Supreme Court's landmark Bruin decision which invalidated restrictive 'may issue' licensing schemes.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: NY Concealed Carry Case Review
  2. 00:07Sponsor: Established Titles
  3. 01:33Attorney Introduction: Anthony Miranda
  4. 02:01Case Overview: Baldi v. City of New York
  5. 02:12Historical NY Concealed Carry Standards
  6. 02:30The 'Proper Cause' Requirement
  7. 02:45Supreme Court Reviews the Issue (Bruin)
  8. 02:58Second Amendment Text & Historical Tradition
  9. 03:19Post-Bruin NY Laws: CCIA
  10. 03:40New Restrictive Gun Laws in NY
  11. 03:58The Baldi Case Details
  12. 04:14Baldi's Carry License History
  13. 04:33Baldi's Business Background
  14. 04:46Baldi as a Police Officer
  15. 04:58Denial of Baldi's Renewal
  16. 05:26Reasoning for Denial
  17. 05:57Legal Challenge and Appellate Process
  18. 06:13Lower Court Ruling
  19. 06:27Main Question for Supreme Court
  20. 06:40Potential Case Outcomes (Mootness)
  21. 06:59New York Law Changes (CCIA)
  22. 07:21GVR and Supreme Court Action
  23. 07:43Conclusion and Future Implications

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Baldi v. City of New York case about?

The Baldi v. City of New York case concerns a police officer's denied renewal for an unrestricted concealed carry permit. It is seeking Supreme Court review, examining New York's historical 'proper cause' standard and its current laws post-Bruin decision.

What was the significance of the NYSRPA v. Bruin Supreme Court decision?

The Bruin decision struck down New York's 'may issue' concealed carry licensing scheme, ruling that the state's requirement for 'proper cause' was unconstitutional as it violated the Second Amendment's historical tradition of firearms regulation.

What is the Concealed Carry Improvement Act (CCIA) in New York?

The CCIA is New York's legislative response to the Bruin decision. It introduced a new, more restrictive system for concealed carry permits, designating numerous locations as 'sensitive places' where carrying firearms is prohibited.

What are the potential outcomes for the Baldi case at the Supreme Court?

The Supreme Court could deem the Baldi case moot due to New York's changed laws (CCIA) and the Bruin ruling, or they could GVR (Grant, Vacate, Remand) the case back to a lower court for reconsideration in light of Bruin.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Armed Scholar

View all →