Supreme Court JUST ANNOUNCED SHOCKING NEWS!

Chapters

1. 00:00Introduction: Brewing and Public Safety
2. 00:05Missouri Law's Impact on Federal Enforcement
3. 00:26Firearm Brace Classification
4. 00:33Supreme Court to Hear Domestic Violence Law Appeal
5. 00:42Bruin Decision and Second Amendment Protection
6. 00:50New York Proper Cause Law Struck Down
7. 00:56Right to Carry Firearms in Public
8. 01:05Bruin's Text, History, and Tradition Approach
9. 01:15New York Regulation Inconsistent with History
10. 01:20Racial Justice Claims in Gun Rights
11. 01:31Department of Asylum Rules Change
12. 01:37Defense of the Second Amendment
13. 01:51Future of Handgun Carry
14. 02:07Unconstitutional Executive Authority
15. 02:12Legal Gun Sales and Illegal Sales
16. 02:16Gun Rights Advocates and Courts
17. 02:24Racial Justice Arguments in Public Fora
18. 02:34Invocation of Race in Second Amendment Debate
19. 02:50Bruin Decision and Public Defenders Brief
20. 03:04Progressive Gun Regulation Advocates
21. 03:07Bruin Aligns with Social Movement
22. 03:12Race-Based Reasonings and Counter Jurisprudence
23. 03:23Absolutist Historical Account of Right to Bear Arms
24. 03:34Anti-Subordinating the Second Amendment
25. 03:44Civil Rights Mobilization Against Gun Violence
26. 03:51Civil Rights Organizations and Gun Violence
27. 04:02Bruin Decision's Impact on Gun Regulation Schemes
28. 04:21Pistol Stabilizing Brace Testimony
29. 04:31Separation of Powers
30. 04:41Connecticut Delegation
31. 04:44Stolen Firearms
32. 04:50Machine Gun Definition
33. 04:54Mass Shooting in Minority Areas
34. 04:57Congressional Law Changes
35. 05:04Note's Three-Part Structure
36. 05:06Evolution of Racial Justice Claims
37. 05:08History of Gun Rights Activism
38. 05:12Normative Framework for Anti-Subordination
39. 05:17Hampers Communities' Capacities
40. 05:24Internal and External Perspective on Law
41. 05:30Interplay Between Mobilization and Legal Meanings
42. 05:33Meaning of the Second Amendment Today
43. 05:36Ordinary People Asserting Right to Bear Arms
44. 05:40United States versus Orimi
45. 05:43Question in United States versus Rahimi
46. 05:47Rahimi Docket Number
47. 05:50Supreme Court Hearing Rahimi Case
48. 05:52Second Amendment and Federal Authority
49. 05:56Prohibiting Handgun Carry for Domestic Violence Subjects
50. 06:04Bruin and Public Protection
51. 06:09Preventing Family Trauma
52. 06:14New York's Restrictions on Armed Self-Defense
53. 06:23Gun Violence in the South
54. 06:27Lawful Gun Owners vs. Criminal Gun Violence
55. 06:34AK-47 Definition
56. 06:41Significant but Underappreciated Role
57. 06:47Preventing Tragedy and Saving Lives
58. 06:52Consequence of 2023 Decision
59. 06:55Fifth Circuit Overturns Federal Regulation
60. 07:08Outcome of New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruin
61. 07:14Supreme Court of the United States 2022
62. 07:18Change in Lower Court Interpretation of Second Amendment
63. 07:25History of the Second Amendment
64. 07:28Justice Clarence Thomas's Test
65. 07:30Gun-Related Legislation Consistency
66. 07:33Nation's Previous Gun Regulations
67. 07:37Intermediate Scrutiny
68. 07:43Historical Analogues to Laws
69. 07:45Time of Second Amendment Adoption
70. 07:48Incorporation by 14th Amendment
71. 07:57Zaki Rahimi Civil Restraining Order
72. 08:04Good Faith Applications of Bruin
73. 08:08Gun Control Laws Struck Down
74. 08:10Definition Mismatch
75. 08:15Bruin Threatens Certain Laws
76. 08:17Ineffective Public Protection Laws
77. 08:23ATF Audit and Background Check
78. 08:29Bruin Does Not Threaten Effective Laws
79. 08:35Policy Outcome Preference
80. 08:38Post-Bruin Challenges
81. 08:42Misinterpretation of Opinions
82. 08:47Inspiration for Future Actions
83. 08:49Bill Signing
84. 08:52Law Circuit Decision in US v. Rahimi
85. 08:56Panel Struck Down Federal Statute
86. 09:00Personal Stance on Gun Ownership
87. 09:03Restraining Order Allegations
88. 09:08Prohibition on Owning Guns
89. 09:15Search Warrant Execution
90. 09:17Suspected Second Crime
91. 09:21Rifle and Pistol Found
92. 09:25Search Order Rationale
93. 09:28Separate Crime Investigation
94. 09:30Federal District Court Finding
95. 09:32US Code Section 922 G8
96. 09:36Prohibition on Owning Guns Under Court Order
97. 09:45Violation of Statute
98. 09:48Most Serious Offenses
99. 09:50Mandatory Minimums
100. 09:52Domestic Violence Abusers
101. 09:57Government Inaction
102. 10:01Item Submitted vs. Marketed
103. 10:07Despicable Creature
104. 10:13Assisting Disabled Veterans
105. 10:18Violent Assault and Threats
106. 10:26Brace Rule Implementation
107. 10:29Government Charges
108. 10:34Sensitive Places Doctrine
109. 10:39Release from Custody
110. 10:41Civil Restraining Order vs. Pre-trial Detention
111. 10:45Texas Senate Resolution
112. 10:49Rahimi Defies Restraining Order
113. 10:53Preparedness and Split-Second Decisions
114. 10:58Assault with Deadly Weapon
115. 11:02Illegal Gun Possession
116. 11:06Rahimi's Appeal
117. 11:10Northern District of Texas
118. 11:12Second Amendment Challenge Basis
119. 11:16Constitutionality of 18 U.S.C. § 922 G8
120. 11:19Dismissal by Lower Court
121. 11:22Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Appeal
122. 11:26Fifth Circuit Panel Upholds Statute
123. 11:35Height Need for Self-Defense
124. 11:37Teeth of the Law
125. 11:42Walking Out with a Rifle or Shotgun
126. 11:46American Citizens in Cities
127. 11:50Seeking Asylum in Other Countries
128. 11:53Particular Incident Inquiry
129. 11:57Rahimi's Request for Rehearing
130. 12:01Supreme Court Decision in Bruin
131. 12:05Fifth Circuit Reverses Conclusion
132. 12:07Supplemental Briefs
133. 12:09Reargued the Issue
134. 12:11New Panel of Justices
135. 12:15Justices Appointed by Presidents
136. 12:20Fifth Circuit Declares USC 92 G8 Unconstitutional
137. 12:27Application in Texas, Mississippi, Louisiana
138. 12:31Justice Department Petition
139. 12:35Supreme Court to Reverse Ruling
140. 12:37Uphold Federal Statute
141. 12:41Illegal for DV Restraining Order Subjects to Purchase Firearms
142. 12:45Fifth Circuit Court Opinions
143. 12:47Justice Amy Coney Barrett's Descent
144. 12:50Canter v. Bar
145. 12:52Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals
146. 12:58Rejected Government's Claim
147. 13:00Second Amendment Application
148. 13:02Law-Abiding Respectable Citizens
149. 13:04Unanimous Panel Opinion
150. 13:07Justice Barrett's Position
151. 13:09Founding Era Legislatures
152. 13:11Stripping Felons of Right to Bear Arms
153. 13:13Virtue-Based Restrictions
154. 13:17We Are Not Finished
155. 13:24Firearm Brace Functionality
156. 13:36Distribution of Braces
157. 13:40Rule Implementation
158. 13:43Congress Pass a Law
159. 13:44Historical Analogies
160. 13:46Justice Department Analogies
161. 13:48Section 922 G8
162. 13:51Historical Tradition Test
163. 13:52Bruin Standard
164. 13:53English and American Laws
165. 13:55Disarmament of Dangerous People
166. 13:57Going Armed Laws
167. 14:02Colonial and Early State Shy Laws
168. 14:06Justice Department Analogies Listed
169. 14:08February Second Opinion Claims
170. 14:10Disarming Dangerous Classes
171. 14:12Modern Law Differences
172. 14:15Purpose of Dangerousness Laws
173. 14:18Preservation of Political and Social Order
174. 14:20Protection of Identified Person
175. 14:22Specific Threat
176. 14:25Judge James C Ho's Concurrence
177. 14:27Expanded Concurrence
178. 14:29March 2nd Judgment
179. 14:31Civil Protective Orders Misuse
180. 14:33Tactical Device in Divorce Proceedings
181. 14:35Issued Without Actual Threat
182. 14:37Judge Wilson's Argument
183. 14:40Mutual Protective Order
184. 14:41Domestic Violence Victims in Greater Danger
185. 14:45Use Weapons for Defense
186. 14:47Abusers
187. 14:53Fifth Circuit's Dangerous Decision
188. 14:55Extreme Decision
189. 14:57February 2nd, 2023
190. 15:00Three-Judge Panel
191. 15:01Federal Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals
192. 15:03Federal Prohibition on Gun Possession
193. 15:06Domestic Violence Restraining Orders
194. 15:08Unconstitutional Under Second Amendment
195. 15:10Conventional Wisdom
196. 15:12Republicans Support Gun Legislation
197. 15:17Highest and Mandatory Minimum Details
198. 15:26Summary of Law
199. 15:31Demonstrating Blind Loyalty
200. 15:36Speaker D. Feeling
201. 15:39Upholding Oath of Office
202. 15:41Message Amendment
203. 15:43Presidential Veto
204. 15:47Opinion Affects Three States
205. 15:49Fifth Circuit States
206. 15:54Extremely Dangerous Decision
207. 15:56Vacated or Put on Hold
208. 15:58Ultimately Reversed
209. 16:00Gutting Public Safety Law
210. 16:02Endangering Domestic Violent Survivors
211. 16:07Wrongly Decided
212. 16:09Reckless Logic of Bruin
213. 16:12Eventually Overturned
214. 16:14Bruin Correctly Applied on Appeal
215. 16:16What Happens Next in Court
216. 16:18Department of Justice Prosecution
217. 16:20Responsible for Prosecuting Rahimi
218. 16:22Determine Whether to Appeal
219. 16:26Enhanced Background Checks
220. 16:29Young People Under 21
221. 16:31Government Protect Its People
222. 16:33Murders Types of Disputes
223. 16:38Settled by Yelling
224. 16:41Settled with Guns
225. 16:43Ask First
226. 16:45Full 16 Judge Panel
227. 16:47Rehear the Case
228. 16:50DOJ Seek Rehearing
229. 16:53Full Fifth Circuit
230. 16:55Vacate the Panel Decision
231. 16:57Hold Off Dangers
232. 16:59Armed Abusers
233. 17:01Further Review
234. 17:04On Bon Review
235. 17:06Full Court Reaches Same Decision
236. 17:08Near Certain Supreme Court Review
237. 17:10Dangerous for Women in America
238. 17:12Gun Laws Protecting Victims
239. 17:15Important Public Safety Laws
240. 17:17Central Focus for Every Town
241. 17:20Broader GVP Movement
242. 17:23Average Women Shot and Killed
243. 17:25Intimate Partner
244. 17:29Presence of Gun in DV Situation
245. 17:31Five Times More Likely to Be Slain
246. 17:36Immediate and Drastic Practical Effects
247. 17:38Three Fifth Circuit States
248. 17:41Hopeful Panel Decision Vacated
249. 17:43Further Review Proceeds
250. 17:46Deeply Concerned Protections May Fall Away
251. 17:47Texas, Louisiana, Missouri
252. 17:50DVRO Subjects
253. 17:52Prohibited Under Federal Law
254. 17:54Subject to Prosecution for Having Firearms
255. 17:59Inspired by Next Generation
256. 18:00Time for Big Change
257. 18:03Rewrote Rules of Asylum
258. 18:05Perceived Degree of Violence
259. 18:08Selling More Guns
260. 18:14Important First Step
261. 18:19Bump Fires
262. 18:23Bumpfire Stock
263. 18:25Not Based on Violence
264. 18:27Based on Threats
265. 18:29Gangs
266. 18:32Legal Challenges Likely
267. 18:33State-Level Laws
268. 18:35Prohibiting Gun Possession
269. 18:38Worst Case Scenario
270. 18:40Domestic Abusers Pass Background Check
271. 18:42Gun Dealer
272. 18:4547 States Outside Fifth Circuit
273. 18:49Fifth Circuit Panel Opinion Misapplied Bruin
274. 18:51Bruin Correctly Applied on Appeal
275. 18:53Opinion Will Be Overturned
276. 18:55Challenge Will Ultimately Fail
277. 18:59Dismissed Out of Hand
278. 19:00Bruin and Heller Emphasis
279. 19:02Second Amendment Protects Law-Abiding Responsible People
280. 19:06Contrary to Bruin's Instructions
281. 19:08Law Unconstitutional
282. 19:10Government Did Not Identify Historical Twin
283. 19:13DVRO Prohibitor
284. 19:15Identical Precedent
285. 19:18Early American History
286. 19:21Fifth Circuit Misunderstood Bruin
287. 19:22Evaluate Gun Safety Law
288. 19:24Unprecedented Societal Concern
289. 19:29DVRO Prohibition
290. 19:31Panel Decision Should Be Reversed
291. 19:33Opening Doors to Dangerous Opinions
292. 19:36Bruin Supreme Court Decision
293. 19:38New York Concealed Carry Law
294. 19:40Disapproved Similar Laws
295. 19:42Five Other States
296. 19:44Significantly Changed Analysis
297. 19:46Evaluate Second Amendment Challenges
298. 19:48Putting into Question Existing Decisions
299. 19:52Upholding Core Gun Laws
300. 19:56Heller Decision
301. 19:589-Year-Olds Killed in Shooting
302. 20:00Horrific Event
303. 20:04Federal Agent Identification
304. 20:10Real Background Checks
305. 20:12Stop Illegal Guns
306. 20:14Shall Not Be Infringed
307. 20:15Infringe Definition
308. 20:17Banning Parts on Firearms
309. 20:19Against the Constitution
310. 20:21Affect Us Here
311. 20:24Breath of Fresh Air
312. 20:26Second Amendment People
313. 20:28Extraordinary Courage
314. 20:31Retell the Story
315. 20:33Anti-Gunners
316. 20:36Keep Guns Out of Lawful Citizens' Hands
317. 20:38New York State
318. 20:40Inviting Gun Lobby Efforts
319. 20:42Attack Public Safety Protections
320. 20:44Because of Bruin
321. 20:46America in Danger
322. 20:48Hazardous Fifth Circuit Decision
323. 20:50Correct Application of Bruin
324. 20:52Further Review
325. 20:54Fifth Circuit Will Be Reversed
326. 20:56Domestic Violence Laws Will Be Safe
327. 20:58Panel Decision Vacated
328. 21:00Ultimately Reversed
329. 21:02Survivors of Domestic Hurt
330. 21:04Three States
331. 21:06Life Ore Crisis
332. 21:09Offenders May Have Ready Access to Firearms
333. 21:12Rahimi Decision Impact
334. 21:14Every Town's Strategy
335. 21:17Strongest Gun Safety Protections
336. 21:19Domestic Violence Laws
337. 21:21Bruin Changed Analysis
338. 21:24Evaluate Second Amendment Challenges
339. 21:27Gun Safety Laws Advocated
340. 21:30Remain Constitutional
341. 21:32Under That Analysis
342. 21:35Core Gun Laws Will Be Upheld
343. 21:36Correct Strategy for GVP Movement
344. 21:39Reduce Gun Violence
345. 21:41Arming Domestic Subjects
346. 21:45Zachi Rahimi Drug Dealer
347. 21:48History of Armed Violence
348. 21:50Model Citizen
349. 21:52Federal Appeals Court Judge
350. 21:55Rod and March
351. 21:57Considerable Understatement
352. 21:59Vacated Conviction
353. 22:01Federal Law
354. 22:03Domestic Violence Orders
355. 22:05Violated Second Amendment
356. 22:08Supreme Court to Hear Case
357. 22:11Applied History-Based Test
358. 22:13Government Powerless to Disarm
359. 22:16Domestic Violence Law
360. 22:19Chances of Justices Hearing Case
361. 22:21Good Chances
362. 22:23Case Started in 2019
363. 22:26Assaulted Girlfriend
364. 22:28Threatened to Shoot Her
365. 22:30Obtained Restraining Order
366. 22:32Suspended Handgun License
367. 22:34Prohibited from Possessing Firearms
368. 22:37Denying Power Grab
369. 22:40Executive Branch
370. 22:42Uptick in Violence
371. 22:44Astronomical Gun Violence
372. 22:48Civil Rights Movement
373. 22:50Showed Up Here
374. 22:52Felt Good About Doing This
375. 22:54Felt Empowered
376. 22:56Abuse of Administrative Procedures Act
377. 23:01Difficult Question to Understand
378. 23:07Enormously High
379. 23:10Protect Myself
380. 23:13Mr. Rahimi Defied Order
381. 23:16Flagrant Fashion
382. 23:18Threatened Different Woman
383. 23:20Assault with Deadly Weapon Charges
384. 23:24Opened Fire in Public
385. 23:26Five Times
386. 23:29Upset About Social Media Post
387. 23:31Sold Drugs
388. 23:33AR-15 Rifle
389. 23:35Fast Food Restaurant
390. 23:37Declined Friend's Credit Card
391. 23:40Fired Bullets into Air
392. 23:42Shootings Led to Search Warrant
393. 23:43Rahimi's Home
394. 23:46Charged with Violating Federal Law
395. 23:47Judge Rejected Second Amendment Challenge
396. 23:50Pleaded Guilty
397. 23:52Sentenced to More Than 6 Years
398. 23:56US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
399. 23:58Affirmed Conviction
400. 24:00Short Decision
401. 24:02Law Violated Second Amendment
402. 24:04Footnote
403. 24:06Appeals Reverse Course
404. 24:08Supreme Court Issued Decision
405. 24:10Establishing New Test
406. 24:12Gun Control Laws Constitutional
407. 24:15Focused on History
408. 24:17Unanimous Three-Judge Panel
409. 24:19Ruled Law Prohibiting Firearms
410. 24:21Domestic Violence Orders
411. 24:23Violated Second Amendment
412. 24:25No Historical Support
413. 24:26Almost a Year Later
414. 24:29Supreme Court Announced New Approach
415. 24:30New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruin
416. 24:34Justices Set to Meet
417. 24:36Discuss Hearing Appeal
418. 24:38Biden Administration's Appeal
419. 24:41Court Often Hears Appeals
420. 24:43Federal Laws Unconstitutional
421. 24:46United States v. Rahimi
422. 24:49Number 22-915
423. 24:51Explore Scope of New Test
424. 24:53Requires Government to Identify Historical Analogues
425. 24:55Justify Laws Limiting Second Amendment Rights
426. 24:59Doesn't Care About Separation of Powers
427. 25:01Texas House of Representatives
428. 25:04Impeach Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
429. 25:09Guns Lost by ATF
430. 25:13Unsure of Question
431. 25:16Incumbent Upon Congress
432. 25:18House of Representatives
433. 25:20Missouri Law Exposes People to Harm
434. 25:24Interfering with Federal Enforcement
435. 25:27Firearms Regulations
436. 25:30Unconstitutional Violation
437. 25:31Second Amendment Rights
438. 25:34General Matter
439. 25:36Justice Clarence Thomas
440. 25:38Majority Opinion in Bruin
441. 25:39Ordinary Law-Abiding Citizen
442. 25:41Biden Administration
443. 25:43Justices in New Case
444. 25:45Strong Historical Evidence
445. 25:47General Principle
446. 25:48Government May Disarm Dangerous Individuals
447. 25:51Fifth Circuit Rejected Analogues
448. 25:53Old Laws Identified by Government
449. 25:55Did Not Sufficiently Resemble
450. 25:57Domestic Violence Orders
451. 26:00Many of Them
452. 26:02Judge Cory T Wilson
453. 26:04Disarm Classes of People
454. 26:06Considered Dangerous
455. 26:08Unwilling to Take Oath of Allegiance
456. 26:09Slaves and Native Americans
457. 26:11That Was Different
458. 26:13Domestic Violence Orders
459. 26:15Case-by-Case Judgments
460. 26:16Particular Individual's Dangerousness
461. 26:19Lawyers for Administration
462. 26:20Questioned That Distinction
463. 26:22Bizarre
464. 26:24Legislators Could Disarm Dangerous Individuals
465. 26:26Categorical Presumptions
466. 26:28Individualized Judicial Findings
467. 26:30Judge Wilson Appointed by Trump
468. 26:32Donald J Trump
469. 26:35Government's Insistence
470. 26:37Not Law-Abiding
471. 26:39Speeders Stripped of Right
472. 26:41Keep and Bear Arms
473. 26:43Political Non-Conformists
474. 26:45People Who Do Not Recycle
475. 26:47Drive an Electric Vehicle
476. 26:50Judge Wilson Conceded
477. 26:52Salutory Policy Goals
478. 26:54Protect Vulnerable People
479. 26:56Bruin Decision Approach
480. 26:58Weigh Benefits Against Burdens
481. 27:02Ancestors Would Never Have Accepted
482. 27:04Law on Domestic Violence Orders
483. 27:08Judge James C Ho
484. 27:11Appointed by President Trump
485. 27:13Concurring Opinion
486. 27:14More Effective Ways
487. 27:16Protect Victims of Domestic Abuse
488. 27:18Individuals Who Commit Acts of Violence
489. 27:20Including Domestic Violence
490. 27:22Should Not Only Be Disarmed
491. 27:24Detained, Prosecuted, Convicted, Incarcerated
492. 27:29Criminal Justice System
493. 27:31Punish Criminals
494. 27:32Prevent Further Crimes
495. 27:36Domestic Violence Orders
496. 27:37Civil Justice System
497. 27:39Subject to Misuse
498. 27:42Concerns Raised by Scholars and Judges
499. 27:44Potential Misuse of Civil Protective Orders
500. 27:46Tactical Devices in Divorce Proceedings
501. 27:51Without Actual Threat of Danger
502. 27:52Judge Ho Found it Challenging