Q&A 51: Troop Trials, Postwar MG34/42, and the DIY Maker's Match

Published on June 29, 2021
Duration: 65:55

This Q&A episode from Forgotten Weapons covers various firearms topics, including the post-WWII use and conversion of the MG34 by Norway, the viability of the MG42/MG3 today, and the differences between prototype and troop trials. Ian McCollum also discusses the challenges of adopting new firearms during wartime and the practicalities of chambering modern handguns in 7.65mm French.

Quick Summary

Norway was the only country to re-chamber MG34 machine guns after WWII, converting them to .30-06 Springfield and later attempting a largely unsuccessful conversion to 7.62x51mm NATO. The MG34's lower rate of fire was often preferred over the MG42's high rate for ammunition management.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Patreon Support
  2. 00:40Real-Time History Franco-Prussian War Campaign
  3. 02:06WWI/WWII Patent Respect & New Gun Adoption
  4. 06:27Post-War MG34 Use & Norwegian Conversions
  5. 10:42MG42/MG3 Viability & MG5 Advantages
  6. 13:34Prototype vs. Troop Trials
  7. 17:44Modern Handgun/PDW in 7.65mm French
  8. 20:19Least Appropriate Backup Gun Match Entry
  9. 21:08Indian INSAS Rifle
  10. 21:38M16 Magazine Anti-Tilt Followers
  11. 22:52HK Mark 23 for Home Defense
  12. 25:29Firearm Collection Sales & Auction Value
  13. 27:56Forgotten Weapons Archive Project Update
  14. 29:19Left-Handed Forgotten Weapons
  15. 30:23YouTube Collaboration Ideas
  16. 31:46Delayed Blowback vs. Locked Action
  17. 33:17Borchardt as a Bullpup?
  18. 34:06Contacting Companies for Research
  19. 36:11Impact of COVID-19 on Work
  20. 37:36Firearms Sent to China & Markings
  21. 40:32Revolving Rifles & Their Drawbacks
  22. 43:01Surplus Firearm Market Status
  23. 45:46French Small Arms Modifications (Pre-WWI)
  24. 50:38Why Handgun Cartridges Don't Use Spitzer Bullets
  25. 53:40French Foreign Legion Weapon Procurement
  26. 54:48Semi-Pistol Grips on Lever Actions
  27. 55:10Calico M950 Reliability Issues
  28. 56:25DIY Gun Stigma & Maker's Match
  29. 58:11Firearms Book Reprint Economics
  30. 61:39Handling Firearms in Foreign Countries
  31. 63:16MAS 49 vs. FN 49 Comparison
  32. 65:01Rum Preferences
  33. 65:30Conclusion & Thanks

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Norway re-chamber any MG34 machine guns after WWII?

Yes, Norway was the only country to re-chamber MG34s. They converted several thousand to .30-06 Springfield (designated MG 34 F1) and later attempted a conversion to 7.62x51mm NATO, which proved largely unsuccessful due to various technical issues.

What are the main advantages of the modern MG5 over the older MG42/MG3?

The MG5 is lighter due to modern materials like polymer and aluminum. It also features a lower rate of fire, which significantly reduces ammunition consumption compared to the MG42's very high rate, making it more practical for sustained infantry use.

Why didn't countries adopt new firearms like the Madsen LMG during WWI?

Setting up new firearm manufacturing is complex and time-consuming. During WWI, countries were already occupied with producing existing weapons. Additionally, obtaining the technical package from neutral countries like Denmark (for the Madsen) was difficult, as they were unwilling to be seen as arms suppliers.

What is the primary reason handgun cartridges don't use spitzer bullets?

Spitzer bullets are long and pointed for better ballistics in rifles. For handguns, the overall cartridge length must be short to fit in the grip. A spitzer bullet would make the cartridge too long, and the ballistic benefits are minimal at typical handgun ranges where trajectory is less critical.

Is the surplus firearm market dead?

The surplus firearm market is not dead, but the availability of large, new batches of military firearms is decreasing. Import restrictions on full-auto firearms limit access to many Cold War era weapons, making existing and previously imported semi-automatic surplus firearms more valuable.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →