Smyth Busters: Can You "Over-Clean" a Gun?

Published on November 15, 2022
Duration: 7:09

This video debunks the myth that firearms cannot be over-cleaned, focusing on the wear and tear associated with frequent full disassembly. It highlights that repeatedly driving pins or removing parts can damage friction-fit surfaces, especially in polymer frames. The presenters recommend annual full disassembly at most, unless the firearm has been submerged or heavily fouled, and suggest alternative cleaning methods for polymer guns to minimize wear.

Quick Summary

You can 'over-clean' a firearm, not from solvents, but from the physical act of disassembly. Repeatedly removing pins and screws, especially in polymer frames, causes wear on friction-fit surfaces, leading to looseness. For many firearms, annual full disassembly is sufficient, with alternative cleaning methods like using gun scrubber and compressed air recommended for polymer frames to minimize wear.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: The Over-Cleaning Myth
  2. 00:44Wear from Disassembly: Pins and Screws
  3. 01:11Full Disassembly vs. Field Stripping
  4. 01:45Polymer Frame Wear
  5. 02:33Cleaning Polymer Frames
  6. 03:01Service Guns: 1911 and Others
  7. 03:33Risk of Losing Parts
  8. 04:00AR-15, M1 Garand, Browning Hi-Power
  9. 04:38Barrel Cleaning Frequency
  10. 05:06.22LR Firearms: Barrel vs. Receiver
  11. 05:28Parts Falling Out During Field Strip
  12. 06:02Historical Cleaning Practices
  13. 06:33Conclusion: Myth Busted

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you actually damage a firearm by cleaning it too much?

Yes, you can 'over-clean' a firearm, not necessarily from the cleaning solvents but from the physical act of disassembly and reassembly. Repeatedly taking apart firearms, especially those with friction-fit pins or screws, can cause wear on the surfaces, leading to looseness and reduced retention over time.

What is the main risk associated with frequent full disassembly of a firearm?

The primary risk of frequent full disassembly is the wear and tear on the firearm's components. Pins held by friction, screws, and surrounding materials (especially polymers) can degrade with repeated removal, compromising the firearm's structural integrity and how parts fit together.

Are there specific types of firearms that are more prone to damage from over-cleaning?

Firearms with polymer frames are particularly susceptible to wear from frequent disassembly because the pins and screws can loosen the polymer material over time. Additionally, firearms with many small, easily dislodged parts, like certain lever-action rifles, pose a risk of losing critical components during cleaning.

What are recommended alternatives to full disassembly for cleaning certain firearms?

For firearms with polymer frames, it's recommended to use polymer-safe gun scrubber and compressed air to clean exposed internal parts without full disassembly. This method effectively cleans the firearm while minimizing the wear associated with taking it completely apart.

More Gunsmithing & DIY Videos You Might Like

More from Brownells, Inc.

View all →