FG-42 vs BAR in the 2 Gun Action Challenge Match

Published on May 18, 2014
Duration: 17:33

This video provides an expert analysis by Ian McCollum comparing the FG-42 and the M1918A3 BAR in a competitive shooting scenario. The comparison highlights the significant weight disadvantage of the BAR (21.4 lbs loaded) and its less ergonomic design for dynamic shooting compared to the FG-42. The analysis covers performance across multiple stages, concluding that the FG-42 is a superior design for this type of competition.

Quick Summary

Expert Ian McCollum of Forgotten Weapons compares the FG-42 and M1918A3 BAR in a 2-gun action challenge match. The BAR's heavy 21.4 lb loaded weight and awkward ergonomics proved disadvantageous against the FG-42, which was deemed a superior design for the competition due to its lighter weight and shoulder rifle configuration.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison
  2. 01:49Stage 1: Truckin'
  3. 03:45Stage 2: Left and Right
  4. 07:11Stage 3: Stop-n-Drop
  5. 09:34Stage 4: Bad Day at the Pistol Range
  6. 11:36Final Assessment and Conclusions

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the main disadvantage of the M1918A3 BAR in the action challenge match?

The M1918A3 BAR's primary disadvantage was its significant weight, approximately 21.4 lbs loaded, which negatively impacted mobility and physical exertion during dynamic shooting stages compared to the lighter FG-42.

How did the FG-42 perform against the BAR in the competition?

The FG-42 generally outperformed the M1918A3 BAR in the action challenge match. Its design as a true shoulder rifle offered better ergonomics and maneuverability, leading to better stage times for its operator, Ian McCollum.

What specific design flaws of the BAR were criticized?

Criticisms of the BAR included its heavy weight, poor sights, a bipod that required a tool to adjust and spun, and overall awkward ergonomics, leading to the conclusion that it was an outdated design even before World War II.

Who is Ian McCollum and what is his expertise?

Ian McCollum is the host of Forgotten Weapons and is recognized as a high-authority expert in historical firearms. His expertise is demonstrated through deep historical knowledge and practical experience with vintage weapon systems, including diagnosing their flaws during use.

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →