Springfield Armory's DUEL: M1 v 1911

Published on August 25, 2014
Duration: 4:11

This video compares the Springfield Armory M1A National Match in .308 Winchester against the Springfield Armory EMP 9mm pistol across accuracy, penetration, and speed shooting. The M1A demonstrated superior accuracy and penetration, while the EMP excelled in rapid firing due to lower recoil. The comparison highlights the distinct roles and performance characteristics of a battle rifle versus a compact pistol.

Quick Summary

The Springfield Armory M1A National Match (.308) and EMP 9mm pistol were compared for accuracy, penetration, and speed. The M1A excelled in accuracy and penetration, while the EMP was faster to shoot due to lower recoil. The .308 round penetrated 5-6 water jugs, whereas the 9mm penetrated 3.

Chapters

  1. 00:17Introduction: Firearm Comparisons
  2. 00:46Accuracy Test Setup
  3. 01:10M1A Accuracy Results
  4. 01:33EMP Accuracy Results
  5. 01:41Penetration Test Setup
  6. 01:52M1A Penetration Test (.308)
  7. 02:14EMP Penetration Test (9mm)
  8. 02:31Penetration Test Results
  9. 02:43Speed Shooting Test Setup
  10. 03:10M1A Speed Test Results
  11. 03:27EMP Speed Test Results
  12. 03:30Speed Test Analysis (Recoil)
  13. 03:39Concealability Discussion
  14. 03:54Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the Springfield Armory M1A and EMP compare in accuracy?

In the video's accuracy test, the Springfield Armory M1A National Match in .308 Winchester produced a notably tighter group, indicating superior inherent accuracy compared to the Springfield Armory EMP 9mm pistol, which showed more scattered results.

What were the penetration test results for the M1A and EMP?

The .308 Winchester ammunition from the M1A penetrated approximately five to six water jugs, while the 9mm ammunition from the EMP penetrated about three water jugs, demonstrating the .308's greater penetration power.

Which firearm was faster to shoot in the speed test?

The Springfield Armory EMP 9mm was faster, completing a nine-shot test in 2.85 seconds compared to the M1A's 3.07 seconds. This speed advantage is attributed to the 9mm's significantly lower recoil.

What ammunition was used for the penetration test?

For the penetration test, the M1A used 150-grain .308 Winchester Black Hills Ammo with Hornady GMX bullets. The EMP used 115-grain 9mm Barnes Tac-XPD ammunition.

Related News

All News →

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Talk Media

View all →