Girsan MC P35 PI Follow Up Video - Fixed? Hi-Power Clone

Published on June 4, 2023
Duration: 11:54

This follow-up video addresses feeding issues with the Girsan MC P35 PI, a Hi-Power clone. The primary suspected cause is a tight extractor claw, leading to rounds not fully chambering. Testing with hotter defensive ammunition (Federal Gold Dot and HST) resolved the malfunctions, indicating the firearm may require a break-in period or consistent use of hotter loads. The video also notes a significant shift in point of impact with different ammunition types.

Quick Summary

The Girsan MC P35 PI experienced consistent feeding malfunctions where rounds would only chamber halfway. The suspected cause is a tight extractor claw. Testing revealed that using hotter defensive ammunition like Federal Gold Dot and HST (+P) resolved these issues, suggesting the firearm may need a break-in period or hotter loads for reliable cycling.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Girsan MC P35 PI Follow-Up
  2. 00:22Original Review Issues: Jamming and Malfunctions
  3. 00:46Diagnosing the Problem: Tight Extractor Claw
  4. 01:52Chamber Smoothness Test
  5. 02:13Accelerating Break-in: Steel Case Cycling
  6. 03:24Extractor Claw Design: Lack of Taper
  7. 04:23Testing Hotter Ammunition: Gold Dot
  8. 05:33Gold Dot Performance and Point of Impact
  9. 06:32Gold Dot Reliability: Zero Issues
  10. 07:00Testing Hotter Ammunition: HST +P
  11. 07:58HST +P Performance and Reliability
  12. 08:05Returning to FMJ Ammunition
  13. 08:46Testing FMJ Ammunition: LAX 124 Grain
  14. 09:26FMJ Ammunition Failure: Still Not Running
  15. 10:11FMJ Grouping and Improvement
  16. 10:43Conclusion: Extractor Claw and Ammunition Choice
  17. 11:25Final Thoughts and Summary

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the primary issue with the Girsan MC P35 PI in the original review?

The Girsan MC P35 PI experienced consistent jamming issues where rounds would only chamber about halfway into the chamber, occurring at least once per magazine with every type of magazine tested.

What is the suspected cause of the Girsan MC P35 PI's feeding problems?

The suspected cause is a tight extractor claw. When comparing it to other 9mm pistols, the extractor on the Girsan was notably tighter, making it difficult for the case rim to slide under it during chambering.

How did the presenter attempt to resolve the Girsan MC P35 PI's reliability issues?

The presenter attempted to accelerate the firearm's break-in period by repeatedly chambering steel-cased ammunition, believing the harder steel would help wear down the tight extractor claw faster than brass cases.

Does hotter ammunition resolve the Girsan MC P35 PI's malfunctions?

Yes, testing with hotter defensive ammunition like Federal Gold Dot and Federal HST (+P) completely resolved the chambering issues, indicating that the firearm may require hotter loads for reliable operation, at least initially.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Buckeye Ballistics

View all →