The FBI Said This is the Best Handgun (and Why They’re Wrong)

Published on July 7, 2022
Duration: 23:05

This video critically re-examines the 1987 FBI handgun evaluation, challenging its conclusions. Lead presenter James Reeves, a recognized industry expert from TFB TV, analyzes historical data and conducts modern re-tests. The analysis highlights potential biases in the original evaluation, particularly regarding caliber preference and manufacturer favoritism, and compares historical results with contemporary performance.

Quick Summary

The 1987 FBI handgun evaluation is re-examined, highlighting potential biases in caliber preference (.45 ACP over 9mm) and manufacturer favoritism. While the Smith & Wesson M645 was ranked first, the Glock 17 reportedly achieved higher practical accuracy scores, and the Beretta 92 demonstrated superior reliability.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the 1987 FBI Test
  2. 02:08The Contestants
  3. 03:48Caliber Controversy
  4. 04:46Durability and Torture Testing
  5. 05:52Reliability Data
  6. 08:53Accuracy Evaluation
  7. 10:31TFB TV Modern Re-Test
  8. 14:12Final Rankings and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main criticisms of the 1987 FBI handgun evaluation?

Critics argue the 1987 FBI handgun evaluation exhibited a bias towards .45 ACP over 9mm, potentially penalized Glocks unfairly for shooter-induced malfunctions, and favored American manufacturers like Smith & Wesson, despite other models like the Glock 17 scoring higher in practical accuracy tests.

Which handguns were included in the 1987 FBI handgun evaluation?

The 1987 FBI handgun evaluation included the Glock 17 and 19, Sig Sauer P226 and P220, Smith & Wesson M645 and M459, Beretta M92, Ruger P85, and the ITM AT84 (mistakenly listed as IMI).

How did the Beretta 92 perform in the 1987 FBI handgun test?

The Beretta 92 was found to be the most reliable handgun in the 1987 FBI evaluation, averaging nearly 1,200 rounds between stoppages, indicating a high degree of mechanical dependability during the extensive testing.

What was the outcome of the torture tests in the 1987 FBI handgun evaluation?

During torture tests, Sig Sauer models failed when their trigger guards bent into the trigger mechanism after being struck with mallets, rendering the firearms inoperable. Other durability tests were also conducted.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →