Do NOT use a Pistol for HOME DEFENSE 7| Shotguns VS Pistol | Top Home Defense Guns | 9mm VS 12 Gauge

Published on October 12, 2024
Duration: 0:59

CajunBoyJake, a firearms content creator with practical expertise, demonstrates a ballistic test comparing 9mm hollow point ammunition and 12 Gauge birdshot for home defense. The test highlights the significant over-penetration risk of 9mm rounds through multiple simulated walls, contrasting it with the safer, reduced penetration of birdshot, which did not exit a final pine board. This practical demonstration emphasizes safety considerations for choosing home defense firearms and ammunition.

Quick Summary

For home defense, 12 Gauge birdshot may be safer than 9mm hollow points due to reduced over-penetration. A ballistic test showed 9mm penetrating 8 walls and exiting a board, while birdshot stopped after one wall, minimizing risk to others in the home.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Shotgun vs Pistol for Home Defense
  2. 00:12The Hollow Point Misconception & Test Setup
  3. 00:29Lethality Testing Standards Explained
  4. 00:419mm Penetration Results
  5. 00:4912 Gauge Birdshot Results

Frequently Asked Questions

Why might a shotgun be better than a pistol for home defense?

A shotgun, particularly with birdshot, may offer reduced over-penetration risk compared to a 9mm pistol. This test showed 9mm hollow points penetrating multiple walls, while birdshot stopped after one, making shotguns potentially safer in environments with loved ones nearby.

Does 9mm hollow point ammunition over-penetrate in homes?

Yes, according to this ballistic test, 9mm hollow point ammunition penetrated 8 simulated walls and exited a pine board. This indicates a significant risk of collateral damage to unintended targets or individuals in adjacent rooms.

Is 12 Gauge birdshot safe for home defense regarding over-penetration?

This test suggests 12 Gauge birdshot is significantly safer regarding over-penetration. It penetrated only one wall and did not exit the final pine board, minimizing the risk to occupants in other parts of the home.

What ballistic testing methods were used to compare 9mm and 12 Gauge?

The test simulated interior walls using drywall and wood framing, followed by a 1/2 inch pine board, similar to historical lethality standards. This rig assessed how many walls each ammunition type could penetrate.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from CajunBoyJake

View all →