Smith VS Sig!...Federal Premium HST .357 Sig vs .40 S&W Ballistic Gel Ammo Test & Review!

Published on October 25, 2024
Duration: 13:45

This video provides a detailed ballistic gel test comparing Federal Premium HST ammunition in .357 Sig and .40 S&W calibers. The instructor, with apparent expertise in firearms testing, analyzes velocity, penetration, and expansion data. While the .357 Sig demonstrates superior raw performance metrics, the instructor discusses practical considerations like ammunition availability and platform development, ultimately favoring the .40 S&W for long-term viability.

Quick Summary

In a ballistic gel test, Federal Premium HST .357 Sig (125gr) averaged 1432 ft/s and penetrated 19 inches, while .40 S&W (165gr) averaged 1140 ft/s and penetrated 17.2 inches. The .40 S&W expanded wider (0.667-0.695") than the .357 Sig (0.552-0.554").

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Test Setup
  2. 00:21.357 Sig vs .40 S&W Comparison
  3. 00:49Federal Premium HST Ammunition
  4. 01:41.40 S&W Specs & Velocity Goals
  5. 01:49.357 Sig Specs & Velocity Goals
  6. 02:11Cartridge Comparison
  7. 02:24Projectile Weight Discussion
  8. 03:02Test Platforms: Glock G22 & G31
  9. 03:22.40 S&W Velocity Testing
  10. 04:40.357 Sig Velocity Testing
  11. 05:31Velocity Comparison Results
  12. 06:10Ballistic Gel Test: .40 S&W Shot
  13. 06:51Ballistic Gel Test: .357 Sig Shot
  14. 07:10Gel Test Results: Overview
  15. 07:23.40 S&W Gel Performance
  16. 07:46.357 Sig Gel Performance
  17. 08:09Penetration Measurements
  18. 08:31Close-up Gel Analysis
  19. 09:10Projectile Examination
  20. 09:42Projectile Weight Measurements
  21. 10:08Expansion Measurements
  22. 10:28Final Comparison & Verdict
  23. 11:08Long-Term Viability Discussion
  24. 12:16Conclusion & Viewer Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the average velocities for the Federal Premium HST .357 Sig and .40 S&W in the test?

The Federal Premium HST .357 Sig (125gr) averaged 1432 ft/s, while the .40 S&W (165gr) averaged 1140 ft/s. These velocities were measured from a 4.5-inch barrel.

How did the Federal Premium HST .357 Sig and .40 S&W perform in ballistic gel regarding penetration?

In the ballistic gel test, the .40 S&W Federal Premium HST penetrated 17.2 inches, and the .357 Sig Federal Premium HST achieved a penetration of 19 inches.

What were the expansion measurements for the HST rounds in .357 Sig and .40 S&W?

The .40 S&W HST expanded to approximately 0.667-0.695 inches in diameter. The .357 Sig HST expanded to approximately 0.552-0.554 inches in diameter.

Which caliber did the instructor favor for long-term viability and why?

The instructor favored the .40 S&W for long-term viability, citing a perceived lack of new development in tooling, ammunition, and platforms for the .357 Sig caliber.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Tools&Targets

View all →