SmythBusters: Buckshot vs. Birdshot Part 2

Published on July 16, 2025
Duration: 8:34

This video from Brownells' Smithbusters series compares buckshot and birdshot for home defense. The hosts, Stephen Caleb and another presenter, use ballistic gel and a Beretta 1301 Tactical shotgun to test penetration and effectiveness at various distances. Their conclusion is that birdshot is insufficient for reliable threat neutralization in a home defense scenario, while buckshot demonstrates significantly superior performance.

Quick Summary

For home defense, buckshot is strongly recommended over birdshot. Tests showed buckshot, like double load buckshot, provides significantly greater penetration and stopping power necessary to reliably neutralize threats in a defensive situation, whereas birdshot proved insufficient.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction
  2. 00:07Home Defense Ammunition Debate
  3. 00:14Smithbusters: Buckshot vs. Birdshot Part 2
  4. 00:31Previous Conclusions
  5. 01:06Theoretical Scenario
  6. 01:40Birdshot Effectiveness Question
  7. 02:02Testing Birdshot
  8. 02:14Test Setup: Beretta 1301, Number 6 Shot
  9. 02:38Birdshot Test Firing
  10. 02:52Birdshot Gel Results (Longer Distance)
  11. 03:47Questioning Birdshot Effectiveness at Closer Range
  12. 03:53Reducing Distance for Birdshot Test
  13. 03:59Birdshot Test at 9 Yards
  14. 04:54Birdshot Gel Results (9 Yards)
  15. 05:26Comparing Birdshot to Buckshot
  16. 05:45Introducing Buckshot Test
  17. 05:53Buckshot Test at 9 Yards
  18. 06:12Test Setup: 9 Pellet Buckshot
  19. 06:36Buckshot Test Firing
  20. 06:43Buckshot Gel Results (9 Yards)
  21. 07:13Buckshot Effectiveness Conclusion
  22. 07:35Ammunition Type Discussion
  23. 07:44Overpenetration Concerns
  24. 08:10Final Verdict: Birdshot vs. Buckshot
  25. 08:16Conclusion: Busted!
  26. 08:19Call to Action & Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

Is birdshot effective for home defense?

Based on ballistic gel testing in the Brownells Smithbusters video, Number 6 birdshot is not considered effective for home defense. It demonstrated insufficient penetration and stopping power, even at closer ranges, making it unreliable for neutralizing a threat.

What type of shotgun ammunition is recommended for home defense?

For home defense, buckshot is strongly recommended over birdshot. Tests showed buckshot, like double load buckshot, provides significantly greater penetration and stopping power necessary to reliably neutralize threats in a defensive situation.

How does clothing affect shotgun ammunition performance?

Clothing can significantly reduce the penetration of shotgun projectiles. This means birdshot, already lacking sufficient penetration, becomes even less effective when a threat is wearing layers of clothing, further highlighting its unsuitability for defense.

What was the setup for the buckshot vs. birdshot test?

The test used a Beretta 1301 Tactical shotgun and ballistic gel. Number 6 birdshot and double load buckshot were fired at distances of approximately 18 yards and 9 yards to compare their penetration and effectiveness.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Brownells, Inc.

View all →