Which SILVER Takes The GOLD?...9MM vs 40 S&W Winchester Silvertip Self-Defense AMMO Test!

Published on May 11, 2024
Duration: 11:14

This video conducts a ballistics gel test comparing Winchester Silvertip 9mm and .40 S&W ammunition through a simulated clothing barrier. The test evaluates bullet expansion, penetration, and velocity from short-barreled handguns. While both calibers performed well, the .40 S&W demonstrated slightly superior penetration and energy transfer.

Quick Summary

In a ballistic gel test comparing Winchester Silvertip 9mm and .40 S&W through a clothing barrier, the .40 S&W (155gr) achieved 19" of penetration and expanded to .548", while the 9mm (115gr) penetrated 15.75" and expanded to .496". Both retained 100% of their weight, with the .40 S&W considered the winner for superior energy transfer.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Setup
  2. 00:17Caliber Comparison: 9mm vs .40 S&W
  3. 00:47Ammunition: Winchester Silvertip
  4. 01:58Test Firearms: Canik MC9 & Glock 27
  5. 02:179mm Velocity Testing
  6. 03:38.40 S&W Velocity Testing
  7. 04:58Ballistics Gel Test Setup
  8. 05:139mm Gel Test Firing
  9. 05:38.40 S&W Gel Test Firing
  10. 05:52Gel Test Results: 9mm Analysis
  11. 06:20Gel Test Results: .40 S&W Analysis
  12. 06:39Penetration Measurements
  13. 07:37Projectile Examination
  14. 08:15Projectile Weight & Expansion Measurements
  15. 09:00Conclusion & Winner Determination
  16. 10:39Viewer Engagement & Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Winchester Silvertip 9mm perform in a ballistic gel test with a clothing barrier?

The Winchester Silvertip 9mm (115gr) from a short barrel averaged 1144 ft/s. It expanded to approximately .490"-.496" and achieved 15.75" of penetration in ballistic gel after passing through a simulated clothing barrier, retaining 100% of its weight.

What were the results of the Winchester Silvertip .40 S&W ballistic gel test?

The Winchester Silvertip .40 S&W (155gr) from a short barrel averaged 1107 ft/s. It expanded to approximately .543"-.548" and achieved 19" of penetration in ballistic gel after a clothing barrier, also retaining 100% of its weight.

Which caliber, 9mm or .40 S&W, performed better with Winchester Silvertip ammunition in this test?

In a direct one-round comparison, the .40 S&W Winchester Silvertip was deemed the winner due to its greater energy transfer and deeper penetration (19" vs 15.75"), despite the 9mm having a slightly higher average velocity from the tested short barrels.

Does Winchester Silvertip ammunition expand reliably through clothing barriers?

Yes, the test demonstrated that Winchester Silvertip ammunition in both 9mm and .40 S&W calibers reliably expands after passing through a heavy clothing barrier consisting of denim, fleece, and cotton t-shirts.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Tools&Targets

View all →