211: Why We Train for Both Proportionality and Utility
This discussion explores the tension between proportionality and utility in the context of violence and warfare. Proportionality acts as a moral constraint, ensuring harm is weighed against valuable goals, while utility focuses on effectiveness. The video emphasizes that unchecked utility can lead to a 'might makes right' scenario, and proportionality can be corrupted by viewing individuals unequally. Developing a true understanding of proportionality and appropriate force is best achieved through practical experience and training, not just abstract thought.










