Barrel Harmonics Testing - Part 1

Published on August 3, 2018
Duration: 35:10

This video explores the impact of muzzle devices and suppressors on rifle accuracy, specifically barrel harmonics. The presenter tests various muzzle brakes, flash hiders, and a suppressor on a Thompson Center Compass and an AR-10, observing significant group size and point of impact shifts. The experiment aims to understand if added weight at the muzzle dampens barrel vibrations and improves accuracy, though the results prove complex and counterintuitive, leading to a need for further testing.

Quick Summary

Adding a suppressor can significantly improve rifle accuracy by dampening barrel vibrations. In tests on a Thompson Center Compass, group sizes improved from over an inch to under 0.8 inches, and on an AR-10, groups also tightened, though less dramatically. This effect is attributed to changes in barrel harmonics caused by the added weight and length.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Barrel Harmonics
  2. 00:55Understanding Barrel Vibrations
  3. 01:58Optimum Barrel Time Concept
  4. 03:04Frustration with Existing Explanations
  5. 04:08Thompson Center Compass Example
  6. 04:58Testing Muzzle Devices
  7. 05:37Compass Test Results (Suppressor vs. Naked)
  8. 08:09AR-10 Test Results (Suppressor vs. Naked)
  9. 09:20White Oak Armament Barrel Surprise
  10. 10:43Muzzle Device Weights Overview
  11. 11:27The Lump Muzzle Device
  12. 11:54Crank Style Brake
  13. 12:30Precision Armament M11
  14. 12:55Herald's Precision Tuner Brake
  15. 13:50DPMS Mitchell 'Ok' Brake
  16. 14:02SilencerCo Flash Hider
  17. 14:21Precision Armament M4-72 Brake
  18. 14:37Pro Comp 762 Brake
  19. 14:52VG6 Gamma 65 Brake
  20. 15:05Sharpshooter X-Ring Barrel D-Resonator
  21. 16:30Hypothesis: Weight Matters
  22. 17:19Ammunition Consistency
  23. 18:05Range Testing Begins
  24. 18:35Lump Muzzle Device (Forward)
  25. 19:19Lump Muzzle Device (Rearward)
  26. 19:57Crank Style Brake Test
  27. 20:35M11 Brake Test
  28. 21:16Herald's Tuner Brake (Weights Forward)
  29. 22:32Herald's Tuner Brake (Weights Rearward)
  30. 23:55DPMS Mitchell 'Ok' Brake Test
  31. 24:41SilencerCo Flash Hider Test
  32. 25:59M4-72 Brake Test
  33. 27:01Pro Comp 762 Brake Test
  34. 27:40VG6 Gamma 65 Brake Test
  35. 28:28Limb Saver (Muzzle Position)
  36. 29:29Limb Saver (Forend Position)
  37. 30:33Confused Results Analysis
  38. 31:08Point of Impact Shift Analysis
  39. 31:47Group Performance Ranking
  40. 33:33Future Testing Plans
  41. 34:43Recommended Resources
  42. 35:04Conclusion & Part 2 Preview

Frequently Asked Questions

How does adding a suppressor affect rifle accuracy?

Adding a suppressor can significantly improve rifle accuracy by dampening barrel vibrations. In tests on a Thompson Center Compass, group sizes improved from over an inch to under 0.8 inches, and on an AR-10, groups also tightened, though less dramatically. This effect is attributed to changes in barrel harmonics caused by the added weight and length.

Does muzzle device weight impact rifle group sizes?

While a common hypothesis is that heavier muzzle devices improve accuracy by reducing barrel whip, testing revealed inconsistent results. Some heavy devices performed well, while others did not, and even lightweight devices like the Sharpshooter X-Ring Barrel D-Resonator showed significant positive effects when placed correctly, challenging the simple weight correlation.

What is barrel harmonics and how does it relate to accuracy?

Barrel harmonics refers to the vibrations that travel through a rifle barrel when a round is fired. These vibrations, which can travel up and down the barrel multiple times before the bullet exits, influence accuracy. Tuning loads or modifying the barrel's harmonic behavior with devices like suppressors or brakes aims to ensure the bullet exits at a consistent point in the vibration cycle.

What are some recommended resources for learning about barrel harmonics?

For those interested in barrel harmonics, resources like Rex's Sniper 101 YouTube series, specifically video 7 on rifle vibrations, and the 'Optimum Barrel Time' paper are highly recommended. These provide detailed explanations of how barrel vibrations affect accuracy and how to tune loads accordingly.

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Johnny's Reloading Bench

View all →