Ken Hackathorn analyzes Red Dot Sights on handguns and gives the pros and cons - Masterclass EP 31

Published on October 19, 2022
Duration: 22:52

Ken Hackathorn provides a balanced perspective on Red Dot Sights (RDS) for handguns, highlighting both advantages and disadvantages based on extensive testing. He notes that while RDS can aid new shooters, experienced marksmen may face a learning curve due to ingrained iron sight habits. Hackathorn emphasizes that RDS offer minimal benefit at typical self-defense distances (0-10 yards) and stresses the importance of enclosed emitters for reliability in adverse conditions.

Quick Summary

Ken Hackathorn argues that red dot sights (RDS) offer minimal advantage at typical self-defense distances (0-10 yards) and require significant training to master, especially for experienced shooters. He prefers enclosed emitters for reliability against environmental factors like dust and moisture.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: RDS Backlash & Balanced View
  2. 01:55Ken's RDS Pistol Collection & Testing
  3. 03:50The Learning Curve: New vs. Experienced Shooters
  4. 05:52Training: Dry Fire vs. Live Fire for RDS
  5. 06:56Distance Advantage vs. Self-Defense Reality
  6. 07:29Quality, Cost, and Mounting Interfaces
  7. 08:47Proficiency: A Perishable Skill
  8. 12:07Enclosed vs. Open Emitters: Reliability
  9. 16:57Historical Context of Optics Trends

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main disadvantages of red dot sights (RDS) on handguns according to Ken Hackathorn?

Ken Hackathorn notes that RDS have a learning curve for experienced shooters, offer minimal advantage at close self-defense distances (0-10 yards), can be expensive, and require consistent training to maintain proficiency. Open emitter designs are also vulnerable to environmental factors.

Does Ken Hackathorn recommend red dot sights for all handgun owners?

Hackathorn suggests RDS are not a universal solution. While beneficial for some, especially new shooters or at longer ranges, they can be a liability for average owners ('99 percent') lacking consistent training. He emphasizes they don't replace fundamental skills.

What is the difference between enclosed and open emitter red dot sights?

Enclosed emitters, like the Aimpoint ACRO, protect the emitter and lens from dust, lint, rain, or snow. Open emitters are more susceptible to environmental contamination, which can cause critical failures, especially in adverse conditions or temperature changes.

How much practice is needed to become proficient with a red dot sight?

Ken Hackathorn states it took him 1,000 rounds to become comfortable and 5,000 rounds for the RDS to feel natural. He stresses that proficiency is a perishable skill requiring consistent practice, especially for those who don't train frequently.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Wilson Combat

View all →