Did Tennessee Just One-Up Texas in Deadly Force Law?

Published on April 29, 2026
Duration: 17:24

This video provides an expert-level analysis of Tennessee's new SB 1847, comparing it to Texas's property defense laws. It details when deadly force may be justified for property protection in Tennessee, emphasizing the 'reasonable belief' standard and potential issues with the 'facing away' exclusion. The discussion contrasts this with Texas law, highlighting differences in how juries evaluate reasonableness for property crimes versus person crimes, and the explicit allowance for shooting fleeing suspects in the back in Texas.

Quick Summary

Tennessee's SB 1847 expands justified deadly force for property protection, including trespass and aggravated cruelty to animals, based on reasonable belief. However, a key exclusion prevents justification if the suspect is facing away. This differs from Texas law, which explicitly allows shooting fleeing suspects in the back after certain night-time property crimes, with reasonableness assessed by a jury.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: TN vs TX Property Defense Law
  2. 01:30Tennessee SB 1847 Explained
  3. 02:04Operative Provision: Justified Deadly Force in TN
  4. 03:13The 'Reasonable Belief' Standard
  5. 04:17Aggravated Cruelty to Animals & Trespass Issues
  6. 05:00The 'Facing Away' Exclusion in TN Law
  7. 06:24Texas Penal Code 9.42: Property Defense
  8. 07:37Texas: Night Time Crimes & Fleeing Suspects
  9. 08:45Texas vs. TN: Jury Evaluation & Presumptions
  10. 10:07Castle Doctrine vs. Property Defense
  11. 10:21Conclusion & Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Tennessee's new law regarding deadly force for property protection?

Tennessee's SB 1847 allows justified use of deadly force if a person reasonably believes it's immediately necessary to prevent or terminate specific crimes like trespass, arson, theft, or aggravated cruelty to animals. However, it excludes situations where the suspect is facing away.

How does Tennessee's new property defense law compare to Texas's?

Tennessee's SB 1847 is seen as potentially friendlier for property defense, explicitly including aggravated cruelty to animals. Texas law, while robust, has specific 'night time' requirements for certain offenses and explicitly allows shooting fleeing suspects in the back, with reasonableness assessed by a jury.

What are the key differences in how Texas and Tennessee evaluate deadly force for property crimes?

Texas law allows a jury to evaluate the reasonableness of using deadly force against fleeing suspects after property crimes. Tennessee's new law introduces an 'facing away' exclusion, which could complicate jury deliberations, and its justification is based on reasonable belief, not automatic presumption of reasonableness.

Can you use deadly force against someone trespassing in Tennessee under the new law?

Yes, under Tennessee's SB 1847, a person may be justified in using deadly force if they reasonably believe it's immediately necessary to prevent or terminate a trespass, provided the suspect is not facing away and other conditions are met.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Armed Attorneys

View all →