Philly Mayor Just Said Second Amendment Wasn't Written For AR-15s, AK-47s, Or Multiple Shot Clips

Published on March 1, 2023
Duration: 11:20

Colion Noir critically analyzes Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney's assertion that the Second Amendment does not protect modern firearms like AR-15s and AK-47s. Noir counters by citing historical mass violence predating the amendment and the Founders' awareness of evolving firearm technology. He argues that restricting rights based on technological advancement is a flawed premise, drawing parallels to the First Amendment's application to modern communication.

Quick Summary

Colion Noir refutes Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney's claim that the Second Amendment doesn't cover AR-15s or AK-47s. Noir cites historical massacres predating the amendment and the Founders' awareness of evolving firearm technology, arguing that restricting rights based on technological advancement is flawed.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Tragedy in Philadelphia & Mayor's Response
  2. 00:14Mayor's Alcohol Sales Comparison
  3. 01:21Regulatory Rebuttal: Background Checks
  4. 01:50Scope of the Second Amendment Debate
  5. 02:15Historical Mass Violence Pre-2A
  6. 03:11Evolution of Firearm Technology
  7. 04:111st vs. 2nd Amendment Logic
  8. 05:15Money and Gun Manufacturing Claims
  9. 05:36Cost of Exercising Rights
  10. 06:48Police Investigation Update
  11. 09:34Safety vs. Gun Control Grades
  12. 10:41Final Thoughts on Empowerment

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Mayor Jim Kenney's argument regarding the Second Amendment and modern firearms?

Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney argues that the Second Amendment was intended for single-shot muzzle-loading firearms used against the British, not for modern weapons like AR-15s or AK-47s with high-capacity magazines.

How does Colion Noir refute the Mayor's historical interpretation of the Second Amendment?

Colion Noir counters by citing historical massacres that occurred before the Second Amendment's ratification and highlighting the Founders' understanding of evolving firearm technology, including advancements in the 18th century.

What comparison does Colion Noir make between the First and Second Amendments?

Noir draws a parallel, suggesting that if the Second Amendment is restricted to the technology of its time (muskets), then the First Amendment should logically be restricted to the communication technologies available when it was written, excluding the internet.

Does Colion Noir believe gun owners profit from exercising their rights?

No, Colion Noir argues that gun owners actually incur costs to exercise their rights, including taxes, licenses, training, and background check fees, directly contradicting the idea that the Second Amendment debate is solely about profit.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Colion Noir

View all →