Stinchfield | Dana Loesch: "At Some Point the Supreme Court is Going to Have to Weigh In" - 6/27/17

Published on June 27, 2017
Duration: 2:20

This video discusses the implications of a Ninth Circuit Court decision on Second Amendment rights, highlighting disagreements among federal circuits. It emphasizes the Supreme Court's eventual need to weigh in on the definition of 'carrying' a firearm, referencing Justice Thomas's dissent and the Heller decision. The discussion also touches on the potential retirement of Justice Anthony Kennedy and the importance of appointing Second Amendment-friendly justices.

Quick Summary

The Supreme Court is expected to weigh in on gun carry rights due to conflicting rulings among federal circuit courts. Justice Thomas, in a dissent, referenced the Heller decision, asserting that 'carrying' a firearm means being secure in one's person anywhere, not just at home.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Must-Take Case for Supreme Court
  2. 00:07Federal Circuits Disagree on Gun Rights
  3. 00:19California Sheriffs and Reasonable Cause
  4. 00:38Justice Thomas's Dissent and Heller
  5. 00:53Defining 'Carry' in Heller
  6. 01:11Ninth Circuit Decision and Future Cases
  7. 01:30Justice Kennedy's Potential Retirement
  8. 01:36Importance of Second Amendment Justices
  9. 01:46Supreme Court's Inevitable Involvement

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does the Supreme Court need to weigh in on gun carry rights?

The Supreme Court must weigh in because federal circuit courts have conflicting decisions regarding the interpretation of Second Amendment rights for carrying firearms. This disagreement leaves the law unclear for citizens across different jurisdictions.

What did Justice Thomas say about carrying firearms in his dissent?

Justice Thomas argued that the Supreme Court, in the Heller decision, already defined what 'carrying' a firearm means. He stated it includes carrying on one's person and being secure in one's person wherever one is, not just within the home.

What is the situation with gun carry laws in California?

In California, some sheriffs have informed residents that they can only carry a firearm if they can demonstrate a 'reasonable cause' to fear for their life, creating a subjective standard for exercising Second Amendment rights.

Why is the potential retirement of Justice Kennedy significant for gun rights?

The potential retirement of Justice Kennedy is significant because it presents an opportunity to appoint a new justice. Advocates for Second Amendment rights emphasize the need to ensure that any new appointee is supportive of constitutional gun rights.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →