US Supreme Court Justice: Second Amendment "...NOT the Right of an Individual.."

Published on October 13, 2016
Duration: 6:46

Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer expressed a view that the Second Amendment primarily pertains to the regulation of state militias and not an individual's right to own a firearm for personal defense. This perspective, shared by other liberal justices, highlights the potential impact of upcoming presidential elections on the interpretation and future of Second Amendment rights.

Quick Summary

Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer interprets the Second Amendment as primarily concerning the regulation of state militias, not an individual's right to own a firearm for personal defense. This perspective highlights the critical role of upcoming presidential elections in shaping the future of Second Amendment jurisprudence.

Chapters

  1. 00:08Introduction and Interview Context
  2. 00:17Justice Breyer on Charlie Rose Show
  3. 01:12Justice Breyer's Anti-Gun Stance
  4. 02:08Quote: Breyer on the Second Amendment
  5. 02:32Charlie Rose's Question to Breyer
  6. 02:41Breyer's Interpretation of the 2nd Amendment
  7. 03:36Right to Keep and Bear Arms Explained
  8. 03:44Not an Individual Right to Own a Gun
  9. 04:06Supreme Court Justice's View on Individual Rights
  10. 04:23Supreme Court Deadlock and Future Impact
  11. 05:01Election's Impact on Second Amendment
  12. 05:31Call to Action: Share Information
  13. 06:10Subscribe for Second Amendment News
  14. 06:41Stay Safe and Vigilant

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Justice Stephen Breyer's interpretation of the Second Amendment?

Justice Stephen Breyer believes the Second Amendment was historically intended to regulate state militias and prevent a federal army from infringing on state security, rather than to protect an individual's right to own a firearm for personal defense.

How does Justice Breyer's view on the Second Amendment differ from others?

Breyer's view contrasts with the interpretation that the Second Amendment secures an individual's right to self-defense. He emphasizes its connection to militia service, suggesting it doesn't cover an individual's right to keep a gun at home.

Why is the upcoming presidential election significant for Second Amendment rights?

The next president will appoint Supreme Court justices. Given the court's current deadlock and differing interpretations of the Second Amendment, these appointments will significantly influence the future legal landscape of gun rights for decades.

What historical context does Justice Breyer cite for the Second Amendment?

Justice Breyer references the Federalist Papers, explaining that concerns existed about Congress potentially disbanding state militias and replacing them with a federal army. The amendment was seen as a safeguard against this.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

View all →