USCCA Gun Law Update - California and Hawaii's Gun Control Battle (Sensitive Locations)

Published on January 18, 2025
Duration: 17:25

This video discusses the legal challenges in California and Hawaii following the Bruin decision, specifically concerning 'sensitive locations' where firearm carry is restricted. It details the legal battles, including the May v. Bon and Woolford cases, and the Ninth Circuit's handling of interlocutory appeals. The analysis highlights concerns about the interpretation of the Bruin decision's history and tradition test by lower courts.

Quick Summary

California and Hawaii are facing legal challenges over 'sensitive locations' restrictions on firearm carry following the Bruin decision. Cases like May v. Bon and Woolford argue that broad prohibitions in places like businesses serving alcohol and their parking lots infringe on Second Amendment rights, despite states' efforts to comply with 'shall issue' CCW requirements.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: May v. Bon and Woolford Cases
  2. 00:33Backstory: Bruin Decision and Sensitive Locations
  3. 01:35State Response: Heavily Regulating CCW Carry
  4. 02:03Bruin Majority and Concurring Opinions on Sensitive Locations
  5. 02:36California & Hawaii's 'Every Square Inch' Approach
  6. 03:35Examples of Restricted Locations (Alcohol Sales, Parking Lots)
  7. 04:20Judge Carney's Preliminary Injunction
  8. 05:07State Appeal to the Ninth Circuit
  9. 05:16Three-Judge Panel's Problematic Review
  10. 05:49Understanding Interlocutory Appeals
  11. 06:28Ninth Circuit Panel Exceeds Authority?
  12. 07:05Pathway to On Banc Review
  13. 07:23Three-Judge Panel's Mixed Ruling
  14. 08:10Appeal for On Banc Review
  15. 08:48On Banc Panel Declines Review
  16. 09:11Judge Van Dyk's Dissent
  17. 10:09Judge Van Dyk's Critique of Bruin Analysis
  18. 10:36Three-Judge Panel's 'Analogous Law' Argument
  19. 11:13Extrapolation from Historical Trespass/Poaching Laws
  20. 12:14Extrapolating to Modern Retail Establishments
  21. 13:02Panel Acknowledges Bizarre Disparity
  22. 13:30The Concept of 'Uncivil Obedience'
  23. 14:38Judges' Reluctance for Historical Analysis
  24. 15:20Current Status for CA/HI Residents
  25. 15:53Appeal to the US Supreme Court
  26. 16:03Underlying Case Still Pending
  27. 16:32Conclusion: Still in Flux, Not a Win
  28. 17:05Future Updates and Contact Information

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the 'sensitive locations' legal challenges in California and Hawaii?

Following the Bruin decision, California and Hawaii enacted laws restricting firearm carry in numerous 'sensitive locations.' These laws are being challenged in cases like May v. Bon (CA) and Woolford (HI), arguing they overreach the Second Amendment's protections by broadly prohibiting carry in places like businesses serving alcohol and their parking lots.

What was the Ninth Circuit's role in the sensitive locations cases?

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reviewed preliminary injunctions related to these laws. Initially, a three-judge panel issued a ruling that critics argue exceeded its authority by reviewing the case de novo instead of just for abuse of discretion. The full on banc court later declined to rehear the case.

How did the Bruin decision impact gun laws in California and Hawaii?

The Supreme Court's Bruin decision mandated that firearm regulations must be consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. This led states like California and Hawaii, previously 'may issue' states, to adopt 'shall issue' CCW permits but also to implement broad 'sensitive location' restrictions to regulate carry.

What is the current legal status of 'sensitive locations' laws in CA and HI?

The legal landscape remains in flux. While a preliminary injunction was partially granted and then appealed, the Ninth Circuit's refusal to rehear the case means the three-judge panel's decision stands for now. Further appeals to the Supreme Court are possible, and the underlying cases are still progressing through the courts.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from USCCA

View all →