Federal HST vs Speer Gold Dot vs Hornady Critical Duty | FBI "Heavy Clothing” Ballistics Gel Test

Published on June 29, 2018
Duration: 15:26

This video provides a detailed comparison of three popular self-defense ammunition types: Federal HST, Speer Gold Dot, and Hornady Critical Duty, tested under the FBI's 'Heavy Clothing' protocol using 20% ballistic gelatin. The host, demonstrating high authority as a ballistics reviewer, highlights the critical role of barrier penetration in terminal performance, with the Federal HST showing superior expansion and retention compared to the other two rounds under these challenging conditions.

Quick Summary

The FBI 'Heavy Clothing' test using 20% ballistic gelatin revealed significant differences in self-defense ammunition performance. Federal HST 124gr 9mm Luger excelled, expanding reliably and penetrating 14.5 inches. Speer Gold Dot 124gr and Hornady Critical Duty 135gr struggled to expand through the fabric layers, highlighting the importance of barrier penetration testing.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to FBI Heavy Clothing Test
  2. 00:54Test Materials and Setup
  3. 01:18Ammunition Selection
  4. 02:57Federal HST Test Results
  5. 04:14Speer Gold Dot Test Results
  6. 05:30Hornady Critical Duty Test Results
  7. 07:38Modified Test: Removing Denim
  8. 08:31Speer Gold Dot Re-test
  9. 10:08Hornady Critical Duty Re-test
  10. 11:02Final Projectile Analysis

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Federal HST perform in the FBI 'Heavy Clothing' ballistic gel test?

The 124gr Federal HST 9mm Luger successfully expanded and retained its weight, penetrating 14.5 inches into 20% ballistic gelatin after passing through four layers of fabric, demonstrating robust terminal performance.

Did Speer Gold Dot expand reliably through heavy clothing barriers?

In the FBI 'Heavy Clothing' test with four fabric layers, the 124gr Speer Gold Dot struggled to expand reliably, over-penetrating the ballistic gel. However, it performed excellently when the denim layer was removed.

What are the key differences between Federal HST, Speer Gold Dot, and Hornady Critical Duty in barrier tests?

Federal HST 124gr showed the best performance through heavy clothing barriers, expanding reliably. Speer Gold Dot 124gr and Hornady Critical Duty 135gr had issues expanding through the full fabric stack, indicating barrier penetration is a critical factor.

Why is testing ammunition through barriers like clothing important for self-defense?

Testing through barriers simulates real-world scenarios where ammunition must penetrate clothing before reaching its intended target. This ensures reliable expansion and terminal ballistics, crucial for effective self-defense.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 1ShotTV

View all →