M1 Carbine versus SKS: Milsurp Showdown

Published on August 19, 2021
Duration: 21:04

This comprehensive review by Chris Baker of Lucky Gunner Ammo pits the American M1 Carbine against the Soviet SKS in a military surplus showdown. Baker details their historical context, technical specifications, market value, and performance in accuracy and reliability tests. While both are popular 1940s semi-auto carbines, the M1 Carbine offers lighter weight and better ergonomics, whereas the SKS is more affordable and rugged, though prone to slam fires. For serious home defense, a modern AR-15 is recommended over both surplus options.

Quick Summary

The M1 Carbine is lighter and has better ergonomics than the SKS, firing .30 Carbine from 15/30 round mags. The SKS is heavier, uses a 10-round fixed mag loaded by stripper clips, fires the more powerful 7.62x39mm, and is generally more rugged. Accuracy at 100 yards favors the M1 Carbine slightly.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: M1 Carbine vs SKS
  2. 01:30M1 Carbine Overview and Specs
  3. 02:24SKS Overview and Specs
  4. 03:35Historical Context of SKS
  5. 05:39Market Value and Customization
  6. 08:24Optic Mounting Solutions Tested
  7. 11:08Accuracy and Range Testing (100 & 300 Yards)
  8. 13:42Ballistics and Practical Use
  9. 15:41Reliability Issues and Fixes
  10. 18:27Final Verdict: M1 Carbine vs SKS vs AR-15

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the M1 Carbine and the SKS?

The M1 Carbine is lighter (5.9 lbs loaded) with better ergonomics and higher capacity magazines (15/30 rounds), firing the .30 Carbine round. The SKS is heavier (9.2 lbs loaded), uses a fixed 10-round internal magazine loaded by stripper clips, fires the more powerful 7.62x39mm cartridge, and is generally more rugged.

How do the M1 Carbine and SKS perform in terms of accuracy?

In range testing at 100 yards, the M1 Carbine averaged 3.3-inch groups, slightly outperforming the SKS which averaged 4-inch groups. Both cartridges experience significant drop at 300 yards.

What are common reliability issues with the M1 Carbine and SKS?

M1 Carbines can be finicky with magazines, especially commercial variants. SKS rifles are generally robust but can suffer from 'slam fires' if the firing pin sticks; a firing pin with a return spring is a recommended solution.

Is the SKS or M1 Carbine better for home defense?

While both are popular surplus carbines, the M1 Carbine's lighter weight and higher capacity are advantageous. However, for serious home defense, the video recommends a modern AR-15 platform over either surplus option due to its superior ergonomics, modularity, and modern features.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Lucky Gunner Ammo

View all →