MP-40 vs PPSh-41 (w/ John Keene)

Published on August 16, 2025
Duration: 11:39

This expert comparison, featuring John Keene, delves into the nuances of the MP-40 and PPSh-41 submachine guns. It highlights their distinct design philosophies, focusing on ergonomics, rate of fire, magazine capacity, and stock design. The discussion also touches upon their historical battlefield preferences and current market values, offering a comprehensive overview for firearm enthusiasts.

Quick Summary

The MP-40 offers superior ergonomics and a slower, more controllable rate of fire, making it easier for beginners to handle and achieve accuracy. In contrast, the PPSh-41 provides greater firepower with its higher rate of fire and larger magazine capacity, but requires more advanced shooter skill for effective control.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: MP-40 vs PPSh-41
  2. 01:10Initial Preferences: Keene vs. McCollum
  3. 02:22Technical Comparison: Capacity & Production
  4. 03:48Rate of Fire & Controllability
  5. 05:15Magazines and Stocks
  6. 06:37Portability vs. Shootability
  7. 08:00Beginner Friendliness & Market Status
  8. 10:55Auction Value & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the MP-40 and the PPSh-41 submachine guns?

The MP-40 features a slower, more controllable rate of fire and better ergonomics, making it easier for beginners. The PPSh-41 boasts a higher rate of fire, larger magazine capacity (especially with the drum), and simpler production, offering more firepower but demanding greater shooter skill.

Which submachine gun is considered more controllable, the MP-40 or the PPSh-41?

The MP-40 is generally considered more controllable due to its significantly slower rate of fire, which allows for easier single-shot accuracy. The PPSh-41's rapid fire necessitates more advanced techniques to maintain control during sustained bursts.

How do the magazines and stocks of the MP-40 and PPSh-41 compare?

The PPSh-41's fixed wood stock provides a superior cheek weld and stability compared to the MP-40's folding metal stock, which can become wobbly. While PPSh-41 drum magazines are reliable, they often require fitting, whereas MP-40 magazines are typically more interchangeable.

What is the market value difference between the MP-40 and PPSh-41?

Original C&R MP-40s generally command higher prices at auction than comparable quality PPSh-41s. This is partly attributed to the MP-40's more iconic status in American popular culture and media.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →