MP-40 vs PPSh-41 (w/ John Keene)

Published on August 16, 2025
Duration: 11:39

This review compares the iconic WWII submachine guns, the German MP-40 and Soviet PPSh-41. While the MP-40 offers better ergonomics and a slower, more controllable rate of fire favored by beginners, the PPSh-41 excels in raw firepower with higher velocity and capacity. Both have distinct design philosophies, with the MP-40 prioritizing portability for troops and the PPSh-41 focusing on mass production and effectiveness.

Quick Summary

The PPSh-41 offers higher velocity and easier production with a faster rate of fire, while the MP-40 provides a slower, more controllable rate of fire ideal for beginners. The MP-40's folding stock can become wobbly, whereas the PPSh-41's fixed wood stock offers better stability.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: MP-40 vs PPSh-41 Debate
  2. 01:10Initial Preferences: Keene vs. McCollum
  3. 02:22Technical Comparison: Firepower & Production
  4. 03:48Rate of Fire & Controllability Explained
  5. 05:15Magazines and Stocks: Reliability & Feel
  6. 06:37Design Philosophy: Portability vs. Shootability
  7. 08:00Beginner Friendliness & Market Status
  8. 10:55Auction Value and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the MP-40 and PPSh-41 submachine guns?

The PPSh-41 fires a higher velocity 7.62x25mm Tokarev round and has a faster rate of fire, often using a 71-round drum. The MP-40 fires 9mm Parabellum, has a slower, more controllable rate of fire, and is generally considered more ergonomic, though its folding stock can become wobbly.

Which submachine gun is better for beginners, the MP-40 or PPSh-41?

The MP-40 is often recommended for beginners due to its slower, more controllable rate of fire, which makes it easier to manage and fire single rounds accurately. The PPSh-41's high rate of fire can be more challenging for inexperienced shooters to handle effectively.

How do the magazines and stocks compare on the MP-40 and PPSh-41?

PPSh-41 drum magazines are reliable but may need fitting. Its fixed wood stock provides a solid cheek weld. The MP-40's under-folding metal stock is designed for compactness but can become loose and wobbly with use, impacting stability.

What is the market value difference between the MP-40 and PPSh-41?

Original C&R MP-40s generally command higher prices at auction compared to original PPSh-41 examples, even high-quality ones. This is partly due to the MP-40's iconic status in American media and its desirability among collectors.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →