Q&A April 2026: The Good, the Bad, and the Really Dumb

Published on April 25, 2026
Duration: 79:06

Ian McCollum critically analyzes the experimental .30-06 Thompson SMG, deeming it a 'dumpster fire' despite its rarity and high auction price. He contrasts it with more historically significant prototypes like the Persuader and Annihilator I, and discusses earlier .30-06 Thompson experimental rifles. McCollum emphasizes that rarity and uniqueness do not equate to quality or historical importance in firearms development.

Quick Summary

The experimental .30-06 Thompson SMG, despite its rarity and high auction price, is critically assessed by Ian McCollum as a technical failure and a 'dumpster fire.' It featured a unique but unsuccessful delaying mechanism and is considered a dead end in firearms development, overshadowed by more historically significant prototypes like the 'Persuader' and 'Annihilator I.'

Chapters

  1. 01:31Experimental .30-06 Thompson SMG Discussion
  2. 02:46Critique of the .30-06 Thompson's Design
  3. 03:26Internal Mechanism of the .30-06 Thompson
  4. 04:08Comparison to .30 Carbine Thompson
  5. 05:04Historical Documentation of the .30-06 Thompson
  6. 05:47More Significant Thompson Prototypes
  7. 06:31Earlier .30-06 Thompson Rifles

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the experimental .30-06 Thompson SMG?

The experimental .30-06 Thompson SMG, while rare and fetching a high price at auction, is considered a technical failure and a 'dumpster fire' by firearms historian Ian McCollum. It featured a novel but ultimately unsuccessful delaying mechanism and is seen as a dead end in development, not a significant piece of firearms history.

Did the .30-06 Thompson SMG have any unique mechanical features?

Yes, the experimental .30-06 Thompson SMG incorporated a plunger in the face of the bolt. When a cartridge was chambered, this plunger would expand, causing the front of the bolt face to spread into the receiver, creating extra friction to theoretically delay the action.

Was the .30-06 Thompson SMG a well-known firearm?

No, the .30-06 Thompson SMG was not widely known to the general public, but its existence was documented in firearms literature, such as Tracy Hill's book 'Thompson: An American Legend,' meaning it was known within the collector and historical community.

Are there more historically important Thompson prototypes than the .30-06 version?

Yes, Ian McCollum considers the initial Thompson prototypes, the 'Persuader' and 'Annihilator I,' to be far more historically significant. These prototypes had a direct developmental path leading to the production Thompson submachine guns and are considered more important from a firearms development perspective.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →