The Rifle Everyone LOVES to Hate Returns—But is it Actually Better?

Published on March 16, 2026
Duration: 20:05

This review of the FN SCAR 17S Gen 2 highlights significant upgrades over the original model, particularly the hydraulic buffer which noticeably reduces felt recoil and muzzle rise. While FN claims over $1,000 in upgrades, the value proposition is debated, especially for owners of the SCAR 20S. Key improvements include an updated M-LOK handguard, ambidextrous controls, and a refined bolt carrier group, though some components like the stock and safety lever still feel less premium than expected for the price point. The video also touches on suppressor compatibility and potential warranty concerns.

Quick Summary

The FN SCAR 17S Gen 2 introduces significant upgrades like a hydraulic buffer for reduced recoil and muzzle rise, a slimmer M-LOK handguard for improved ergonomics, and enhanced ambidextrous controls. Its backwards-compatible bolt carrier group also offers an upgrade path for older SCAR models.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: The SCAR 17S Gen 2 Returns
  2. 00:57Hydraulic Buffer: The Biggest Upgrade
  3. 02:24Backwards Compatible Bolt Carrier Group
  4. 03:02Suppressor Use and Warranty Concerns
  5. 04:22Viewer Appreciation Draw: Win a SCAR 17S!
  6. 06:16M-LOK Handguard and Ergonomic Improvements
  7. 07:32Included Accessories: Bag and Grip
  8. 08:17Ambidextrous Controls and Safety Enhancements
  9. 10:32Barrel Shoulder for Suppressors
  10. 11:16Upgraded Sights
  11. 12:11AR Grip and Stock Compatibility
  12. 13:09Trigger and Recoil Impulse Comparison
  13. 14:02Downsides: What FN Ignored
  14. 15:49Cheap Feeling Components
  15. 16:52Heat Shield Cover for Suppressed Fire
  16. 17:32Final Thoughts: Is the Gen 2 Worth It?
  17. 18:06Expert Opinion: Not Worth the Upgrade
  18. 19:22Win a SCAR 17S Gen 2: Details

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main upgrades in the FN SCAR 17S Gen 2?

The FN SCAR 17S Gen 2 features a hydraulic buffer for reduced recoil, a thinner M-LOK handguard for better ergonomics, and improved ambidextrous controls. The bolt carrier group is also backwards compatible with older SCAR models.

Does the FN SCAR 17S Gen 2 feel significantly better than the original?

Yes, the Gen 2 SCAR 17S offers a noticeable improvement, particularly in felt recoil and muzzle rise due to the hydraulic buffer. It feels more refined and closer to the SCAR 20S in its shooting characteristics.

Is the FN SCAR 17S Gen 2 worth upgrading from an older SCAR model?

For owners of original SCARs, upgrading the bolt carrier group is a more cost-effective solution. While the Gen 2 has notable improvements, buying a new one may not be worth the cost unless specific new features are highly desired.

What are the potential downsides of the FN SCAR 17S Gen 2?

Some components, like the stock's polymer housing and safety lever, still feel less premium than expected for the price. There are also lingering warranty concerns regarding suppressor use, though this is often anecdotal.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Hegshot87

View all →