H.C.A.R. vs SCAR 17

Published on January 18, 2022
Duration: 16:00

This video provides an expert-level comparison between the FN SCAR 17 and the Ohio Ordnance Works H.C.A.R., hosted by Scott of Kentucky Ballistics. The comparison delves into the technical specifications, operational differences between short-stroke and long-stroke gas piston systems, and performance metrics including destructive testing and handling. Scott, demonstrating high authority and expertise, highlights the H.C.A.R.'s superior trigger feel and manageable recoil, ultimately expressing a personal preference for the H.C.A.R. due to its historical significance and modern enhancements.

Quick Summary

The H.C.A.R. (Heavy Counter Assault Rifle) is a modern interpretation of the BAR, chambered in .30-06 Springfield with a long-stroke gas piston and hydraulic buffer. It features a superior trigger feel and faster reset compared to the FN SCAR 17, which uses a short-stroke gas piston and .308 Winchester. Both calibers demonstrate high kinetic energy transfer, easily destroying cinder blocks.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Visual Teasers
  2. 00:33Host Introduction
  3. 00:46SCAR 17 Technical Overview
  4. 01:20H.C.A.R. Technical Overview
  5. 03:45Mag Dump Comparison
  6. 05:08Steel Target Accuracy
  7. 06:00Destructive Testing: Cinder Blocks
  8. 07:22Food Destruction Tests
  9. 13:30Dual Wielding Finale
  10. 14:09Conclusion and Preference

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the FN SCAR 17 and the H.C.A.R.?

The FN SCAR 17 uses a short-stroke gas piston system and is chambered in .308 Winchester. The H.C.A.R. (Heavy Counter Assault Rifle) is a modern take on the BAR, featuring a long-stroke gas piston system and chambered in .30-06 Springfield. The H.C.A.R. also reportedly has a superior trigger feel and reset.

How do the calibers .308 Winchester and .30-06 Springfield compare in performance based on the video?

Both calibers demonstrate significant kinetic energy transfer, easily destroying cinder blocks. While specific group sizes aren't detailed, the visual tests suggest both are highly effective for destructive purposes. The H.C.A.R.'s .30-06 caliber, combined with its hydraulic buffer, allows for manageable recoil during rapid fire.

What is the expert opinion on the trigger performance of the SCAR 17 versus the H.C.A.R.?

According to Scott from Kentucky Ballistics, the H.C.A.R. possesses a significantly better trigger feel and a faster reset compared to the SCAR 17. This was observed during rapid-fire mag dump tests and contributes to the H.C.A.R.'s perceived advantage in handling and follow-up shot capability.

What makes the H.C.A.R. a modern interpretation of the BAR?

The H.C.A.R. (Heavy Counter Assault Rifle) is presented as a modern evolution of the classic Browning Automatic Rifle (BAR). It retains the BAR's powerful .30-06 Springfield caliber but incorporates modern features like a weight-reduced receiver, a hydraulic buffer system for recoil management, and an adjustable Magpul stock.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Kentucky Ballistics

View all →