Only Fudds Carry a .40 S&W or .357 Sig in 2024

Published on November 19, 2024
Duration: 9:56

This video argues that .40 S&W and .357 SIG are outdated and inferior handgun calibers in 2024 compared to modern 9mm loadings. The speaker, identifying as an 'average 40 caliber hater,' explains that .40 S&W was developed due to FBI agents' inability to handle 10mm recoil, resulting in a 'short and weak' round. The video highlights issues like increased recoil, faster parts breakage in firearms designed for 9mm, lower ammunition capacity, and higher cost, making them less effective for most shooters, especially in self-defense or competitive scenarios. The speaker encourages a switch to 9mm for better performance, capacity, and shootability.

Quick Summary

.40 S&W is considered outdated in 2024 due to its higher recoil, lower capacity, and higher cost compared to modern 9mm ammunition. While developed to address 10mm recoil issues for law enforcement, 9mm now offers comparable effectiveness with better shootability, making it the preferred choice for civilians and agencies alike.

Chapters

  1. 00:06Introduction: .40 Caliber Sucks
  2. 00:20Welcome to Trench Grenade
  3. 00:33Topic: .40 S&W and .357 SIG Discussion
  4. 00:48The 'Fudds' and Comment Section
  5. 01:25Share Your .40 Caliber Stories
  6. 02:06Origin of .40 S&W: The 10mm Connection
  7. 02:36Firearm Design Issues with .40 S&W
  8. 03:49Recoil and Parts Breakage
  9. 04:06Training and Proficiency with 9mm vs .40
  10. 04:46Ballistics and Handgun Effectiveness
  11. 05:00.357 SIG: The Same Argument
  12. 05:16Shot Placement is Key
  13. 05:23Glock 22 and Parts Breakage Evidence
  14. 05:41Why Cops Switched from .40 S&W
  15. 06:04Snappy Recoil and Performance
  16. 06:14Competition Shooters and .40 Caliber
  17. 06:21Capacity Advantage of 9mm
  18. 06:30Revolvers and .45 ACP Outdated?
  19. 06:43Ammunition Cost Comparison
  20. 06:51.357 SIG for Texas Residents
  21. 07:15History Recap: .40 S&W's Flaws
  22. 07:30.40 S&W is Outdated in 2024
  23. 07:50Who Carries .40 S&W Today?
  24. 08:00Law Enforcement Shift to 9mm
  25. 08:14Pros Outweigh Cons for 9mm
  26. 08:22Steering Clear of .40 S&W
  27. 08:36Advice for .40 Caliber Carriers
  28. 08:56The Great Debate: .40 vs 9mm
  29. 09:03Dad Advice from Nighthawk
  30. 09:13Conclusion and Sign Off

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is .40 S&W considered outdated in 2024?

.40 S&W is seen as outdated due to its higher recoil compared to 9mm, which can lead to poorer shooting performance and faster parts wear in firearms not specifically designed for its pressure. Modern 9mm loadings offer comparable or better ballistics with less recoil and higher magazine capacity, making them the preferred choice for most shooters and law enforcement.

What are the main disadvantages of carrying .40 S&W?

The primary disadvantages of .40 S&W include increased recoil, which makes follow-up shots slower and more difficult, lower ammunition capacity in most firearms compared to 9mm, and generally higher ammunition costs. These factors contribute to it being less practical for self-defense and competitive shooting than modern 9mm options.

What is the history behind the .40 S&W caliber?

.40 S&W was developed in the early 1990s by shortening the 10mm Auto cartridge. This was reportedly done because FBI agents found the 10mm's recoil too difficult to manage effectively, leading to the creation of a less powerful, 'short and weak' round that could be chambered in smaller firearms.

Why have law enforcement agencies switched from .40 S&W to 9mm?

Law enforcement agencies have largely transitioned to 9mm due to advancements in ammunition technology that allow 9mm to perform comparably to .40 S&W in terms of effectiveness. 9mm offers advantages like lower recoil for better control and faster shooting, higher magazine capacity, and lower training costs, making it a more practical choice for uniformed officers.

Is .357 SIG a better alternative to .40 S&W?

The video argues that .357 SIG, like .40 S&W, is largely superseded by modern 9mm. While .357 SIG offers higher velocity, it doesn't necessarily translate to a significant practical advantage for most users and often comes with increased recoil and cost, without the widespread benefits of 9mm.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Trench Grenade

View all →