Supreme Court to Hear New York Carry Permit Case | Gun Talk Radio

Published on October 12, 2021
Duration: 18:10

This video discusses the upcoming Supreme Court case challenging New York's 'good cause' requirement for concealed carry permits. Legal scholar Don Kilmer explains how this case, and a related one concerning California gun show regulations, could significantly impact Second Amendment rights nationwide. The discussion highlights the legal arguments against restrictive carry laws and the ongoing fight against what is perceived as governmental overreach in firearm regulation.

Quick Summary

The Supreme Court is hearing a case challenging New York's 'good cause' requirement for concealed carry permits, arguing it unconstitutionally burdens the Second Amendment right to self-defense outside the home. This case, alongside litigation over California gun show regulations, could significantly reshape firearm rights nationwide.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Supreme Court Case on NY Carry Permits
  2. 00:16Major Case Heading to US Supreme Court
  3. 01:18Second Version of Carry Case Before Supreme Court
  4. 02:14History of Carry Cases: Peruta v. California
  5. 03:06Previous New York Carry Case Rendered Moot
  6. 04:09Oral Arguments Scheduled for November 3rd
  7. 04:42New York's 'Good Cause' Requirement Explained
  8. 05:13Inversion of Fundamental Rights in Carry Laws
  9. 06:38Optimism for the Supreme Court Case
  10. 07:28What to Look for in the Court's Opinion
  11. 08:15Standards of Review: Strict vs. Intermediate Scrutiny
  12. 09:00Potential Impact on 'May Issue' States
  13. 11:14California Gun Show Regulations Case
  14. 13:49Round Two of California Gun Show Litigation
  15. 15:08Arrogance and Virtue Signaling in Gun Control
  16. 16:43The Tide is Turning for Second Amendment Rights
  17. 17:30Second Amendment Becoming a Normalized Right

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main issue in the Supreme Court case regarding New York carry permits?

The Supreme Court is reviewing New York's 'good cause' requirement for obtaining a concealed carry permit. Critics argue this requirement places an undue burden on citizens seeking to exercise their Second Amendment right to self-defense outside the home.

How might the Supreme Court's decision impact 'may issue' states?

If the Supreme Court rules against New York's 'good cause' standard, it could force 'may issue' states, which grant permits at the discretion of authorities, to become 'shall issue' states, where permits are granted to all qualified applicants.

What is the significance of the California gun show case discussed?

The case challenges a California law specifically targeting gun shows at the Del Mar fairgrounds. It argues that such targeted restrictions violate both the First Amendment's freedom of assembly and the Second Amendment's right to bear arms.

What legal standards of review are relevant to Second Amendment cases?

Key standards of review include strict scrutiny, intermediate scrutiny, and rational basis review. The Supreme Court's decision may clarify which standard, or an alternative like text, history, and tradition, should be applied to Second Amendment challenges.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Talk Media

View all →