Ask NOIR: .45 vs .10 for concealed Carry?

Published on February 28, 2025
Duration: 10:50

Colion Noir, demonstrating high expertise in practical self-defense applications, compares the FN 545 in .45 ACP and the FN 510 in 10mm Auto for concealed carry. He emphasizes shootability and practical stopping power over raw ballistic potential for typical civilian threats, ultimately recommending the .45 ACP for most users due to its manageable recoil and training cost.

Quick Summary

Colion Noir recommends the FN 545 Tactical (.45 ACP) over the FN 510 Tactical (10mm Auto) for most concealed carry needs. He emphasizes that while 10mm offers more power, the .45 ACP's superior shootability, manageable recoil, and lower training costs make it a more practical choice for civilian self-defense against human threats.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Comparison Setup
  2. 00:44Viewer Inquiry
  3. 01:07Examples of .45 ACP Pistols
  4. 02:31Ammunition Sponsor
  5. 02:54Shared Features of FN 545 & 510
  6. 03:05FN 510 with Weapon Light
  7. 03:34FN 545 Analysis
  8. 04:35FN 510 Analysis
  9. 05:54The Decision Factor: Shootability
  10. 07:12Bear vs. Human Defense
  11. 08:08Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

Which caliber is better for concealed carry, .45 ACP or 10mm Auto?

For most concealed carry situations involving human threats, .45 ACP is often recommended due to its manageable recoil and ample stopping power. While 10mm Auto offers more power, its increased recoil can make follow-up shots slower under stress, making it less ideal for typical civilian self-defense scenarios.

What are the key differences between the FN 545 Tactical and FN 510 Tactical for concealed carry?

The FN 545 Tactical (.45 ACP) provides a softer shooting experience, making it easier to control for faster follow-up shots. The FN 510 Tactical (10mm Auto) delivers significantly more power, which is advantageous for specific threats like dangerous animals, but comes with greater recoil and higher training costs.

Is 10mm Auto overkill for concealed carry against human threats?

According to firearm instructors like Colion Noir, 10mm Auto can be considered overkill for most human threats due to its potent recoil, which can hinder rapid, accurate follow-up shots. For typical self-defense, .45 ACP or even 9mm often provide sufficient stopping power with better shootability.

What factors should I consider when choosing between .45 ACP and 10mm for a carry gun?

Consider your primary threat scenario: .45 ACP is excellent for general self-defense against humans due to manageable recoil and ample power. 10mm Auto excels in situations involving dangerous game or extreme threats where maximum power is paramount, but requires more training to handle effectively.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from Colion Noir

View all →