I Didn't expect this! Goex vs. Pyrodex with Deuce and guns

Published on March 31, 2018
Duration: 13:51

This guide details a method for testing black powder substitutes like Goex and Pyrodex in a black powder revolver using a chronograph. It emphasizes proper chronograph placement to avoid smoke interference, consistent loading procedures with wonder wads and lead balls, and thorough cleaning between tests for accurate velocity readings. The presenter, Deuce, highlights the differences in performance, cleaning, and smell between the two powders.

Quick Summary

Goex is authentic black powder, offering a historical feel and pleasant smell, but is harder to find and more expensive. Pyrodex, a substitute, is widely available, provides higher velocities, and is easier to clean initially, though it's corrosive and has an unpleasant odor. Both are tested with 25 and 30-grain charges in an 8-inch barrel revolver.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Goex vs. Pyrodex
  2. 00:10Introducing Goex 3F Black Powder
  3. 00:23Introducing Pyrodex Triple F
  4. 00:34Chronograph Setup for Black Powder
  5. 00:50Caldwell Chronograph Features
  6. 01:18Testing with 8-Inch Barrel Revolver
  7. 01:35Previous Load Testing Insights
  8. 01:56Testing 25 and 30 Grain Loads
  9. 02:00Loading Pyrodex Powder
  10. 02:23Ensuring Test Consistency
  11. 02:40Using Wonder Wads
  12. 02:46Using Homemade Lead Balls
  13. 03:14Priming with RWS No. 10 Caps
  14. 03:38Cleaning Cylinders for Consistency
  15. 04:07Testing 30 Grains of Pyrodex
  16. 04:49Testing 25 Grains of Goex
  17. 05:55Testing 30 Grains of Goex
  18. 06:19GoPro Behind Chronograph
  19. 06:38Reviewing Test Results
  20. 06:51Projectile Weight and Average Velocity
  21. 07:04Pyrodex 25 Grain Average Velocity
  22. 07:22Goex 25 Grain Average Velocity
  23. 07:43Testing 30 Grain Charge
  24. 08:18Pyrodex 30 Grain Average Velocity
  25. 08:41Goex 30 Grain Average Velocity
  26. 08:57Other Factors: Availability and Cleaning
  27. 09:09Availability of Pyrodex vs. Goex
  28. 09:31Cleaning Residue: Pyrodex vs. Goex
  29. 10:12Smell Comparison: Pyrodex vs. Black Powder
  30. 11:07Chronograph Errors with Smoke
  31. 11:26Conclusion: Pyrodex vs. Goex
  32. 11:36Advantages of Pyrodex
  33. 12:03Downfalls of Pyrodex
  34. 12:07Advantages of Goex Black Powder
  35. 12:17Authenticity and Historical Feel
  36. 12:33Purpose of Black Powder Revolvers
  37. 12:56Recommendation: Choose Goex if Possible
  38. 13:00Outro and Subscribe

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between Goex black powder and Pyrodex?

Goex is true black powder, offering authentic smell and historical feel, but is harder to find and more expensive. Pyrodex is a substitute, readily available, provides higher velocities, and is easier to clean initially, but is corrosive and has an unpleasant smell.

How does powder choice affect black powder revolver performance?

Pyrodex generally yields higher velocities and more energy than Goex with the same charge weight. However, Goex provides a more authentic shooting experience and smell, which is often the primary reason for using black powder revolvers.

What are the cleaning considerations for Pyrodex and Goex?

Pyrodex leaves an acidic residue that must be cleaned immediately to prevent damage. Goex residue is less corrosive but can trap moisture and lead to rust if not promptly addressed.

What is the recommended powder charge for black powder revolvers?

For an 8-inch barrel revolver, 25-grain and 30-grain loads are optimal. Loads below 25 grains can cause ignition issues, while loads above 30 grains may yield diminishing returns. Brass frame revolvers should be kept to 25 grains or below.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from DEUCE AND GUNS

View all →